What is clear is that there is no consensus and when there is no consensus of whether the QB is good enough to be the starter, it usually means they aren't good enough to be the starter.
Whelp, that settles it. The Saints should also buy Rattler and Haener a ticket on the same flight out of New Orleans as Carr, because fans can't come to a consenus on those two either.
By the standard quoted above, Rattler and Haener most likely aren't good enough either, so don't waste any more time on them either.