Mike Garafolo: Saints are set to make a decision on Derek Carr within the next few weeks; likely to have multiple suitors if released

AARPSaint said
The takes on both sides are soooo extreme. Carr is not terrible, nor is he great. He’s average. He doesn’t often turn the ball over, but he doesn’t do much spectacular, either. He’s not a running QB, but he isn’t a statue, either.

To me, the “What to do about Cart?” dilemma has at least a first step in its solution: have an open competition in OTAs and training camp. Then make an informed decision about who the starter should be. Trading or cutting him right now is a very poor option.

The obvious flaw in this scenario is that we don’t know whether or not the Saints will grab a FA QB or trade for one, or draft one. One of those actions would change the picture.

I agree. It's like the old saying goes, one in the hand is better than two in the bush. Carr is in hand and capable enough, so you don't let him go until you've already got an equal or better replacement already in hand.

Getting an "elite" QB in free agency, the draft or by trade takes a lot of resources. I use those resources for other areas of the team that need upgrading like RB, WR, TE, OL and/or DL. I have no idea what Moore will do, but I know he's in a much, much better position to make an informed decision than we are.