Elvis' 2025 cap and roster cleanup proposal

A better way to look at it might be this which is true for any NFL team:

There are three resources to build an NFL team:

1. Draft
2. FA
3. UDFA

All three however are subject to the salary cap. While true the bill never comes due, it does have a hard limit.

The practical effect of the Saints way of managing it is that it’s limiting. Let’s say for the sake of argument a team has $100 to spend to build a roster and $50 is taken up by the QB leaving $50 for the rest of the players. Banking on cap going up to $120 the next year sound great in a vacuum but does present problems.

- that QB might cost $60 the next year or $70
- 31 other teams got that $20 increase as well.
- it might not increase at all.
- a team might spend some of those dollars of which there is only 100 of on a player that doesn’t pan out and can’t be reallocated easily.

While it doesn’t prevent placing a team on the field it might not be the one you want as the other 31 teams have at least some of that $100 on the positive side as opposed to starting out at -$50 each year.

A team can be fielded sure, but it comes at a cost that other teams can get players easier than if for no other reason than they have the $ to do it. The Saints can always find a way but that too comes at a cost on the roster.

Right on cue. And this is why I stay away from salary cap discussion threads. It always leads to these oversimplifications. And the oversimplification always leads to the rationale that you have to cut players until you're under the cap.

Tanking to build is just not a viable solution to winning in the NFL. And having $120 million in cap space doesn't help you become a contender either. We saw Jacksonville give out insane contract amounts for a couple years. We're going to see New England do it soon as well. Because under all of the doom and gloom of having no cap space is the reality that you also have to spend a certain amount of the rolling 5 year cap space as well. These shallow analogies don't take into account how complicated the cap is and perhaps more importantly, the importance of the cost of talent in the league.