Should Rattler be our starter in 2025? (merged)

It does not matter which one is better. Pretty sure Carr is “better” in 2025 but there’s the bigger picture. If we release Carr, take the cap hit and go with Rattler, we can ride his rookie contract a few years while we grow by draft and by building cap space. If we stick with Carr, he gives us a better chance to win in 25, but to win what? The ceiling is win 9 games and take a road trip in the playoffs? Tough call for a new head coach.