Should Rattler be our starter in 2025? (merged)

Got to disagree, no way are they even in my opinion. Poise, pocket awareness, decision making, arm talent, accuracy all fall in favor of Rattler but the most important thing he showed was that he was able to settle down the O and run it, whereas Haener had the O quite frenetic out there.

Just my take. But I’m a Rat man after all
I saw the same thing and I wanted Haener to be great. He's from a couple of towns over from where I am and his Mom was our local new anchor for a really long time. I kind of loved the idea of the local kid getting the QB job for my favorite team. Unfortunately, he doesn't seem to have what it takes for that. So Rattler's my guy until there is someone that's better with more long term upside.