Cap Implications of Keeping and Cutting Derek Carr

I get that and that's a fair point. I'm just saying that I think most of the people who want to cut Carr want to for long term cap reasons vs wanting Rattler to start. I get what you're saying because it's def easy to get locked into the idea of one guy starting, but I think a ton of the discourse is dismissed because people claim the other side only wants one scenario because of an emotional reaction to a player, whether that be Carr or Rattler.
I never said or thought anything about anyone having an emotional reaction. I think some people put too much stock in a QB having a strong arm. That's an issue of people having different priorities. It's not an issue of an emotional reaction as far as I'm concerned.