Ashton Jeanty or Tyler Warren?

livefromDC said
Based on your consistent comparison to Bush, do you think Jeanty will be similar to Bush? If you do, I guess I can see your logic. I think there's a lot of people who see him being similar to Barkley or Tomlinson. Thats why I ask.

But if your point is that he can end up not being as good as people think he will be, that's true for every single position and shouldn't be a determination when drafting a player. You have to trust your evaluation. Look no further than the Saints last few 1st round picks back to Davenport. So what gives with the Bush comparison?

It's not a consistent comparison, I compared him once. And it's not about Jeanty as a player. It's about positional value that I don't think RB has enough of to get one at 9. That's a luxury pick for when you team is good and you trade up because you need a RB more than you need draft picks. We're not that team.

EDIT: Here is an article talking about positional value. NFL teams take less RBs and TEs less than any other positions in the first round. It's not just me that feels that way, NFL GMs feel that way too.