Peterson was many years ago and I don't think McCaffery was an elite prospect. In part because of concerns about durability which have proved to be true. And I don't think Robinson was elite either. And yet, many think he was a better prospect than Jeanty.
I really don't get the blinders people have with Jeanty. He's a very good RB, but it's not clear that he is elite and if he isn't elite then he's not BPA at #9.