The thing is that we don't know what the actual scouts and actual experts think about Jeanty. We just know what the "draft experts" think. We will get a better idea of what the scouts and teams think of him as the draft gets closer and reporters talk to scouts and teams that have made their final evaluations and started stacking their boards.
Maybe he is elite. I don't really know because it's hard to tell how good he really is when he's a guy that counts on breaking a lot of tackles but is doing it against lower level competition. And very few backs end up being great in the NFL based on tackle breaking ability alone. So, he is going to need to show he has quickness that I'm not sure he has.