McCaffrey was an elite prospect and has had multiple years since where he has been considered the best RB in the NFL.
Robinson was elite whether you think so or not. The vast majority of people had him as an elite prospect prior to the draft. Many think Jeanty is better than Robinson.
I also don't get the blinders people have with Jeanty trying to discount him as it is so incredibly obvious that he's an elite talent at RB.