Ashton Jeanty or Tyler Warren?
As someone who isn't on either side of the Jeanty situation the argument is simple.
Pro Jeanty: Elite production, off the charts ability to absorb hits, truly the best player on his team, superstar level of dominance at times despite being the entire defensive gameplan.
"Anti" Jeanty: He played in a really poor conference, RB position is not as valuable, we have other more pressing needs, historically taking a RB this high hasn't lead to great results, he's maybe a tad smaller/ not the greatest long speed.
It's really that simple. Neither side is going to change and both sides have legitimate points.