Underhill thinks Carr will be Saints starter [mod edit: Moore-Carr meeting went well; Saints plan is to keep Carr in 2025 & figure out contract]
Just for fun I went through and looked at every QB in the HOF and double checked their W/L records.
Lets just say the facts speak for themselves and they are not what is being stated.
That's because only QB's on winning teams even get considered for the Hall of Fame.
There have been some really good QB's that never played on a winning team. Archie Manning is one.
Kurt Warner couldn't even make a teams roster for his first several years and now he's in the Hall of Fame. Steve Young played poorly for the hapless Buccaneers before going to the 49'ers.
Warren Moon had to spend his first 6 seasons in the CFL before the NFL even gave him a chance.
The point is that NFL teams don't evaluate and grade QB's on their win-loss record. They evaluate them by watching how they play in every snap that they play. They look at how fast they process and make decisions, if they make good decisions, their release speed, their pocket awareness and elusiveness, and their ball placement. A QB can do all those things perfectly on a play and the play still fails. If the QB does their job perfectly, but a receiver pops up a perfectly placed ball and it goes for a pick six that causes the team to lose, that's not on the QB.
Brees had a whole bunch of late game winning drives that still resulted in losses, because the defense gave up a last second go ahead score to the other team. Carr has one of the highest 4th quarter come back wins in the league and had several other go ahead drives that his defense couldn't protect, just like what happened so often to Brees.
Moore and several other people who work for NFL teams grade Carr higher than most of the repeaters and fans do, because they grade their actual play by play performance and not win-loss record.