Yeah that's the thing. The All In strategy is incredibly bright and shrewd when you have a contender type toster. I was a major advocate for the strategy when we had Brees/SP.
Of course you focus on winning now when you have a first ballot HoF QB and the best HC in franchise history. But they both left. The roster got old. A lot of talent left. To me the strategy makes perfect sense until it starts making no sense whatsoever.