You articulated what I was thinking when comparing Tet vs Jeanty very well. Unfortunately, I don't think Jeanty will make it out of the top 5 (I don't see him lasting pass pick 4 when Vrabel picks). So if we want him, we'll have to trade up which means we'd likely have to give up our 2nd rounder. I really hope if we do trade up, we don't touch next years draft picks.
I'm not even discounting the Browns who lost Chubb and are desperate for a franchise RB as much as they are desperate for a franchise QB. Same goes with the Giants who's offense suffered incredibly so after losing Barkley. You can say they need a QB, but if we can look at the QB's in this draft and realize they're not very good, then certainly the professionals can.
Point being, I think Jeanty is completely off the table for us unless we want to scrap the idea of ever finding a franchise QB in the draft in next years draft and attempt to run a franchise with mediocre/bad QB's for a few years.