John Clayton on Shockey

Miller + EJ = Young + Lake + rookie DT + rookie CB + rookie OG

Shockey = Young + Lake + one rookie - picks next year

No. No it doesn't.

Miller is a backup, EJ is a situational TE. Lake is a backup, Young would be a great situational DT. In fact, EJ + Miller (<) Young + Lake but the fact that DT is more important makes it equal. But its not one or the other....so.....?

And I'm not sure where someone proposed giving up our first three picks for Shockey.