WHich to me is funny because Mike loves to say that Stafford is going to be successful with a change of scenery, but not Jameis despite both QBs having ridiculously similar performances in their first five seasons. I love Mike, but I'm going to trust Sean on this one.
This draft was a weak draft in regards to the Dline. I don’t think Turner would’ve lasted until our 2nd rd pick.I said possibly.... Still... A move up into the 40 - 50 range likely would have landed him in the 2nd... I don't see the value at 28... Again, I hope I am wrong and he's not another "measurables" guy like Davenport... and turns into JJ Watt.... I have never been big on "late risers" in the 1st... There are good reasons they were not there to start, and I think many teams out smart themselves when they do this. JMO
At one time, I liked and agreed with the approach of acquiring more draft picks and getting more players. It seems reasonable that you statistically have a better shot at getting a good player the more times you can dip into the pool. This has been the Patriot way for years.I totally agree that Money Ball doesn't work in the NFL draft. First because you don't have stats against the same competition, but also because I don't think it works in football in general. Baseball comes down to objective stats with a certain amount of randomness based on the sequence of events like hits, strike outs, and walks. But, in the end, the law of averages plays out in baseball so good advanced metric stats really work if the sample size is large enough. Football just can't totally be reduced to objective stats the way baseball can.
Anway, I like the way the Saints draft and the reliance on RAS with the realization that their are exceptions makes sense in reducing the risks. The one criticism I have is that I would like them to trade up less often and do a better job of gathering more draft picks. I realize that there have not been a lot of open roster spots on the team the last few years, but because the draft is such a crap shoot, I like the idea of having more lottery tickets. But, that's a niggle. They have done a great job of building a deep and winning team over a long period of time.
We went for Armstead cause he was simply the fastest OL. We went for jimmy graham despite him not having experience cause he was tall, thick enough and could jump .
Trust me, he was ranked their top 16. I know you are not doing this but it is worth saying that we can question the evaluation/scouting that led to the grade, but the grade is the grade and they highly valued this prospect.I did not like the Turner pick, and I am skeptical that the Saints had him ranked as one of the top 16 players in the draft--NFL coaches are not known for their veracity, especially with regard to their draft selections that receive criticism.
However, if he was ranked in their top 16 players and was the top ranked player on their board at 28, the process demands that you take him and not trade down absent a very compelling offer by another team wanting to move up.
Well said. I also have a notion that Turner will also pan out quite well.Trust me, he was ranked their top 16. I know you are not doing this but it is worth saying that we can question the evaluation/scouting that led to the grade, but the grade is the grade and they highly valued this prospect.
It is kind of like Ryan Ramcyzk. They had such a high grade on Ram. If I remember correctly, he was in their top 15. For the team, the only thing that matters is where they grade the prospect. They ended up being right about Ramcyzk and I have a gut feeling they will be right about Turner.
You needed someone to dance with and the word was, there were no takers to move up. As a result, you stick to your board. If Turner was the highest rated player, then you go with that.I agree completely. That was my thought as well. And with the Jags picking Etienne, I cannot think they would have been concerned about losing him by dropping 3 spots. I thought the Jags spot was ripe for a trade up for Newsome.
|Saints Coach Ryan Nielsen (...can anyone think of an exception)?||Saints Super Forum (Main Board)||12|
|If anyone would like to sound like an insider/expert on UDFA/late-round, here you go.||Saints Super Forum (Main Board)||6|
|NFL Draft Did Dai'Jean Dixon from Nicholls get signed by anyone?||Saints Super Forum (Main Board)||11|
|Using Mike Detillier's Guide to Get a Sense of the Draft (2021 Edition)||Saints Super Forum (Main Board)||4|