Offline
Sure we can split hairs about what 3rd rd picks were great and which were not. If we are to do that, then I’d argue that Jimmy was the best TE that we ever had. AK41 will be (if not already) the best RB we have ever had. Those picks alone supersedes any lackluster picks bc they are bonafide difference makers. For all of the times that we have thrown away picks to grab “our guy”, which one has actually moved the needle for us? If we want to throw away picks, then make it worth while, like for a possible franchise QB. My main issue is that it we make those moves with blinders on. We are so dang set on the way we operate that, to an extent, it’s a fault.I really don't think you want to do that. You listed 3 hits and left off Baun, Trautman, Tre'quan, Anzalone, Grayson, PJ Williams, John Jenkins, Martez Wilson, Johnny Patrick, Usama Young and Andy Alleman. Adebo and Hicks could go either way.
Fact is you have a better chance at acquiring talent in the top 64 than you do after. If anything we've held onto some of those 3rd round picks too long by virtue of their draft position. Using the Payton trade to improve our chances is a win. We didn't give up anything...