As much as it pains for me to say this... We should re-sign Tre'Quan Smith. (1 Viewer)

[Taker597]

The biggest example for keeping him is PJ Williams and that keeping depth with upside is always better than nothing.

PJ Williams had his best season as a Saint and if Smith stays around and continues to improve. He should be a solid depth guy for years to come on the cheap.

He's affordable. He's young with a ton if talent and upside.




I still have beef with him never being available when you need him the most. If he's good 400 yards and a few TDs. He's a good WR3 or WR4 that you gotta keep.

 

[St. Widge]

If you can get him for close to the vet minimum, he's a good option as your #4 WR. But you have to get back Michael Thomas and upgrade the #2 WR spot or he is way to far up the depth chart to be comfortable with him.

Of course, the problem is that he doesn't play special teams as far as I recall and it's hard to be a #4 WR that doesn't play special teams.

 

[abnrgr]

The biggest example for keeping him is PJ Williams and that keeping depth with upside is always better than nothing.

PJ Williams had his best season as a Saint and if Smith stays around and continues to improve. He should be a solid depth guy for years to come on the cheap.

He's affordable. He's young with a ton if talent and upside.




I still have beef with him never being available when you need him the most. If he's good 400 yards and a few TDs. He's a good WR3 or WR4 that you gotta keep.

Agree. He knows the playbook and blocks. Sign him to a one year deal like we have been doing with PJ Williams. Bring in a rookie and veteran. Push TQS down to spot duty (4th WR) and let him earn it in TC.

 

[BayouSAINTJoe]

Nope...let him walk, create as many vacancies we need to create in the WR room to force us to upgrade. Callaway and Harris are the only keepers outside MT13 that I wanna see next year...and I only really want to see Harris as a KR and an occasional deep hitter. But I want a stud WR in the 1st that can be your every down WR that can hit over the top as well.

 

[SweetT]

I would rather not see him back on our team. I refuse to see us lower our standards on a guy who’s biggest compliments is that he knows the playbook, can block, and is veteran minimum cheap. #loweredexpectations

 

[Fiyo]

Nope...let him walk, create as many vacancies we need to create in the WR room to force us to upgrade. Callaway and Harris are the only keepers outside MT13 that I wanna see next year...and I only really want to see Harris as a KR and an occasional deep hitter. But I want a stud WR in the 1st that can be your every down WR that can hit over the top as well.

We probably need to add a rookie with at least one of the top three picks. That said, if TQS comes with a one-year (FINALLY) prove-it deal at the Vet minimum, he's probably worth it for system knowledge and blocking abilities alone. Side note: Lil Jordan came on pretty strong late. Something to also consider.

 

[Chris]

 

[DerrickB]

Walk

 

[ANKOMA33]

Walk

 

[bobad]

Can't count on him, won't play ST, so a soft no.

 

[Saint Kamara]

vet minimum and then I'm still not sure because he is largely wasting your time with having to scramble to replace him when he's injured

 

[No2DC]

Depressing.

 

[B4YOU]

It all comes down to money. I don’t see TQS and his stats demanding 2.5M/yr money from other teams. If we can sign him to #3 WR money 1.3-1.7M/yr, then fine. If he walks, so be it.

 

[SaintsMan209]

camp body

 

[Taker597]

It all comes down to money. I don’t see TQS and his stats demanding 2.5M/yr money from other teams. If we can sign him to #3 WR money 1.3-1.7M/yr, then fine. If he walks, so be it.

Of course.