As rosters stand today how do you rank NFC South (1 Viewer)

Previous Next
Bucs
Saints
Falcons
Panthers
For rosters. The Bucs don’t know how to win yet, imo. But they’re loaded on paper.

ETA: Seeing the dead falcon, I know I know, how dare I not say our team is by far and away the best in the division. Lol ?
 
Last edited:
Saints
Falcons
Bucs
Panthers

It is very close between the Falcons and Bucs. Is Brady really better than Ryan, right now? He might be, and he will have the best receiving options that he has seen for years. But, do the Refs let the Bucs O-line hold like they allowed the Patriots to hold and will he get the Defensive holding and PI calls like he did with the Patriots? Basically, did the Patriots get away with penalties and get some, because they are The Patriots or was it because of Tom Terrific?
 
J.T. said:
Saints
Falcons
Bucs
Panthers

It is very close between the Falcons and Bucs. Is Brady really better than Ryan, right now? He might be, and he will have the best receiving options that he has seen for years. But, do the Refs let the Bucs O-line hold like they allowed the Patriots to hold and will he get the Defensive holding and PI calls like he did with the Patriots? Basically, did the Patriots get away with penalties and get some, because they are The Patriots or was it because of Tom Terrific?
Click to expand...

That’s a great question. Certainly hope it was because of the Patriots and not Tom, else we’re in trouble twice this next season.
 
Still put Falcons second they have an established team while the Panthers and bucs dont
 
If we factor in depth and inevitable injuries: overall Saints, Bucs, Falcons, Panthers. At every commensurate offensive skill player in the division I would take what the Saints have on offense over every other team.

Quarterback: Brees, Brady, Ryan, Bridgewater. Brady is new to the division and gelling with a new team with the coronavirus is going to favor continuity. Taysom Hill as a backup brings a dimension to the overall QB position in short yardage rivals Lamar Jackson or Cam Newton. Running Back: Kamara, McCaffery, Gurley, Jones. McCaffery is a function of volume. He requires so many touches to get his productivity, I would prefer Kamara. Gurley is injury prone. Wide receiver one: Thomas, Jones, Evans, Anderson. Thomas set the NFL record. There is an argument Jones is more talented, but Thomas' numbers speak for themselves. Wide Receiver 2: Sanders, Ridley, Godwin , Moore . Sanders has been in big games and number one wideout in the past. Tight End: Cook, Howard, Hurst, Thomas . Cook's production blows all three away combined. Left Tackle: Armstead, Matthews, Okung, Smith, Left Guard: Peat, Lindstrom, Bailey, Center: McCoy, Mack, Jensen, Paradis, Right Guard: Worford, Carpenter, Mouton, Stinnie Right Tackle: Ramczyk, McGary, Little.

On Defense there are few more individual play makers but again the Saints are loaded with talent. Overall: Saints, Bucs, Falcons, Panthers. With the exit of Kuechly in Caronlina the Panthers D has lost its leader. The Falcons Jarrett and Deon Jones are solid. Neal was good but has been injured twice. Bucs's Shaquill Barrett is a budding star. Suh is overrated. The Bucs secondary is a joke. The only non-Saints players in the NFC South to make the pro bowl on defense were Grady Jarrett and Shaquil Barrett, now that Kuechly is gone. Saints have Jordan, Lattimore, and Davis was robbed.

On special teams the Saints kicker, punter, and return specialist are all the best in the division.
 
Bayareasaint said:
Vegas has us 1 1/2 more wins then the Bucs this season. I was wondering who it was going to be but congrats, your “that”guy. Their roster can’t hold our jock!!!
Click to expand...
Yeah seriously ppl are just waaaaay over hyping Brady hes been in a steady decline even his "mvp" year wasnt all that great
 
Bayareasaint said:
Vegas has us 1 1/2 more wins then the Bucs this season. I was wondering who it was going to be but congrats, your “that”guy. Their roster can’t hold our jock!!!
Click to expand...

Unlike you seem to be with mine, I’m good with your right to feel different. And I care not what Vegas thinks. Who Dat.
 
sainthood said:
If we factor in depth and inevitable injuries: overall Saints, Bucs, Falcons, Panthers. At every commensurate offensive skill player in the division I would take what the Saints have on offense over every other team.

Quarterback: Brees, Brady, Ryan, Bridgewater. Brady is new to the division and gelling with a new team with the coronavirus is going to favor continuity. Taysom Hill as a backup brings a dimension to the overall QB position in short yardage rivals Lamar Jackson or Cam Newton. Running Back: Kamara, McCaffery, Gurley, Jones. McCaffery is a function of volume. He requires so many touches to get his productivity, I would prefer Kamara. Gurley is injury prone. Wide receiver one: Thomas, Jones, Evans, Anderson. Thomas set the NFL record. There is an argument Jones is more talented, but Thomas' numbers speak for themselves. Wide Receiver 2: Sanders, Ridley, Godwin , Moore . Sanders has been in big games and number one wideout in the past. Tight End: Cook, Howard, Hurst, Thomas . Cook's production blows all three away combined. Left Tackle: Armstead, Matthews, Okung, Smith, Left Guard: Peat, Lindstrom, Bailey, Center: McCoy, Mack, Jensen, Paradis, Right Guard: Worford, Carpenter, Mouton, Stinnie Right Tackle: Ramczyk, McGary, Little.

On Defense there are few more individual play makers but again the Saints are loaded with talent. Overall: Saints, Bucs, Falcons, Panthers. With the exit of Kuechly in Caronlina the Panthers D has lost its leader. The Falcons Jarrett and Deon Jones are solid. Neal was good but has been injured twice. Bucs's Shaquill Barrett is a budding star. Suh is overrated. The Bucs secondary is a joke. The only non-Saints players in the NFC South to make the pro bowl on defense were Grady Jarrett and Shaquil Barrett, now that Kuechly is gone. Saints have Jordan, Lattimore, and Davis was robbed.

On special teams the Saints kicker, punter, and return specialist are all the best in the division.
Click to expand...

You would, even at WR?
And on defense I don’t think we are the top. Extremely weak at linebacker, injury questions on the d line.

Totally agree on the specials teams sweep.
 
Humperdoo said:
Brady is washed imo. I’m not basing mine on him at all.
Click to expand...
I mean yeah they have good w/o who make things happen but I think they're gonna regret letting perriman go and I mean their D is meh and ik yhey have arians but he depends on bombs down the field and yeah palmer was old but he could still throw bombs and they only had one good year
 
@Ragnarok I think Brady while being washed physically will still be able to instill a winning culture there, mentoring the young guys. I think Arian is a good coach and I believe they have a great young backer in White and a great young CB in Murphy-Bunting.
 
Humperdoo said:
@Ragnarok I think Brady while being washed physically will still be able to instill a winning culture there, mentoring the young guys. I think Arian is a good coach and I believe they have a great young backer in White and a great young CB in Murphy-Bunting.
Click to expand...
I'll agree they have better lbs I'd say we have the best in the south in Davis but overall unit yea bucs have it right now and maybe with Brady mentoring I just go back to they aren't the Pat's and these players haven't been in that environment and if Brady tries to bring that to them idk how well a lot of them will take it and yeah arians is a good coach but I go back to the general lives and dies by the big play. So I'd put them tied 3rd with Carolina
 
Ragnarok said:
I'll agree they have better lbs I'd say we have the best in the south in Davis but overall unit yea bucs have it right now and maybe with Brady mentoring I just go back to they aren't the Pat's and these players haven't been in that environment and if Brady tries to bring that to them idk how well a lot of them will take it and yeah arians is a good coach but I go back to the general lives and dies by the big play. So I'd put them tied 3rd with Carolina
Click to expand...

All fair points. As I stated in my original I’m just going off of ‘paper’ as they don’t know how to win. That matters imo.

And obviously I want it to be us that finishes first.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Register

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Previous Next

Users who are viewing this thread

    Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)

    Share this page

     

    Twitter

    Back
    Top Bottom