Best RB in NFC south history? (2 Viewers)

[donato]

Even though this is a Saints forum, I still can't believe noone mentioned Mike Alstot.

One of the most overrated players at any position.

 

[greg985]

Literally?

I was refering to the broken link. I'm on my phone and the thread was really wide because of the hyperlink, but now that you fixed it it's all good.

 

[Jhoniten]

One of the most overrated players at any position.

Not sure I would call him overrated, everytime Dunn was hurt, which was often against us, Alstot would go into beast mode.

 

[Dan in Lafayette]

I would have to go with Dunn.

 

[brees#9]

Deuce

 

[thenewpac]

Stephen Jackson? Lol j/k Dulymussssssss

 

[AmerVet]

26 and Dunn are the only ones that stuck out

 

[Ross]

Its boring at work. Thx for the laugh.

So we're not allowed to be optimistic or hopeful?

 

[duhonmark551]

Mike Alttott was a 6 time probowler and 4 time allpro. He is ranked by NFLN as one of the top ten power runners in NFL history. He was better than Dunn who was in the same backfield. He was a fearsome runner with power and speed.

 

[Saint Kamara]

Mark Ingram will be a close second to Deuce when all is said and done.

I wish that would be the case, but sadly it won't be.

 

[Consigliere]

Most of you guys are forgetting the older players. It IS probably Deuce, based on longevity and durability.

But his competitor would be Jamal Anderson. And I hate to say that about a Dirty Bird, but he was dominant. He carried that 1998 team to a Super Bowl all by himself; that team had an average defense and a very mediocre passing game.

 

[Mamba]

Most of you guys are forgetting the older players. It IS probably Deuce, based on longevity and durability.

But his competitor would be Jamal Anderson. And I hate to say that about a Dirty Bird, but he was dominant. He carried that 1998 team to a Super Bowl all by himself; that team had an average defense and a very mediocre passing game.

The NFC South began in 2002.

 

[Pai Mei]

It's Deuce. Alstott was solid, but he was also super over-rated! Deuce was grossly underrated outside of NO.

 

[Consigliere]

The NFC South began in 2002.

Well the OP would have to clarify his question. The four teams in the division began before that.

 

[donato]

Well the OP would have to clarify his question. The four teams in the division began before that.

Why would have have to clarify it? It says NFC South right in the question.