Brees has a 99.8 QB rating and 66.9 completion % all-time in Playoffs. (1 Viewer)

[NOFALCONS10]

Brady has an 89.8 Career playoff QB rating
And only 63.04 career completion % in Playoffs

Brees 16 career playoff games

Brady 41

Fruits of an argument I had with my brother Today.

In case you were wondering Montana is at 95.6 QB rating and 62.67 % completion

 

[BreesusSaves]

I wonder if Brees would have more rings than fingers to wear them if he spent his career with a defense that was top 10 in scoring every season.

 

[NOFALCONS10]

I wonder if Brees would have more rings than fingers to wear them if he spent his career with a defense that was top 10 in scoring every season.

This all started because my loud-mouth brother insists that Brady is 10x better than Brees in the playoffs.

Sorry.

Had to vent, folks.

 

[NOFALCONS10]

Peyton manning is at 87.4 QB rating and 63.1. Completion %.


Haven't checked all the others but I do know that Kurt Warner is at 102.8 QB Rate and 66.45 completion %.

 

[2009ring]

I wonder if Brees would have more rings than fingers to wear them if he spent his career with a defense that was top 10 in scoring every season.

Its not even that, it's that the AFC East hadn't had one real franchise QB in it other than Brady for years. Meanwhile we were going up against Cam and Ryan twice a year.

 

[Taker597]

I wonder if Brees would have more rings than fingers to wear them if he spent his career with a defense that was top 10 in scoring every season.

According to 2010, 2013, 2018, 2019...


Not much more...

Granted 18 and 19 are too little too late

 

[NOFALCONS10]

According to 2010, 2013, 2018, 2019...


Not much more...

Granted 18 and 19 are too little too late

Weren't those years only top 10 in yards allowed for the Saints, not scoring?

 

[Saint Kamara]

I wonder if Brees would have more rings than fingers to wear them if he spent his career with a defense that was top 10 in scoring every season.

If you put Brees with New England and Brady with the Saints since 2006 (14 year window).

Brees - 6 rings
Brady - 0 rings

If you put Brees on the Broncos team from 2012-2015, he wins 3 rings. Manning limped through the playoffs in 2015 for his only ring during this time.

 

[whodatphil]

This is the kinda thing failcons fans do. At some point, gotta stop with the moral victory stats. It doesn’t make anyone feel better. We want another ring

 

[NOFALCONS10]

This is the kinda thing failcons fans do. At some point, gotta stop with the moral victory stats. It doesn’t make anyone feel better. We want another ring

Thats might be true but I'm not quite done.

Brees' SB Qb rating of 114 vs the Colts was higher than any of Brady's SB ratings.

Brady's highest was 110 vs PHilly in 2004

My brother bashes Brees for his performance against the Rams but

Brees vs Rams playoffs

88 QB rating

65% Completion percentage

Brady vs Rams in SB 2018

71 QB rating

60 completion %


He claims we can't win the SB with Brees but

Drew Brees SB stats

114 QB rating

82% completion percentage



Mahomes in SB

2 INTs, 2 Fumbles

Sacked 4x

78.2 qb rating

61% completion



Brees has now gone 5 straight seasons with a 100 or greater QB rating and averages 118 QB rating for his Career when Targeting Can't Guard Mike.

 

[SaintStephen1]

If that was Saints last night, their defense would have given up game winning drive to Niners at end of the game. Instead Mahomes after playing bad for most of the game wins a ring. That’s why judging Brees career by only 1 ring is stupid. He has given team late 4th quarter lead 5 times when his defense imploded.

 

[NOFALCONS10]

If that was Saints last night, their defense would have given up game winning drive to Niners at end of the game. Instead Mahomes after playing bad for most of the game wins a ring. That’s why judging Brees career by only 1 ring is stupid. He has given team late 4th quarter lead 5 times when his defense imploded.

Couldn't stop Kettle on one play to win the game.

 

[NOFALCONS10]

If that was Saints last night, their defense would have given up game winning drive to Niners at end of the game. Instead Mahomes after playing bad for most of the game wins a ring. That’s why judging Brees career by only 1 ring is stupid. He has given team late 4th quarter lead 5 times when his defense imploded.

Brees also scored 6 tds at 41 yrs old on the same D that made Mahomes look like trash.

Brees also had a higher QB rating than Mahomes did last year when he won the MVP.

Im just sick and tired of the disrespect Brees gets. Its appalling.

 

[LiterOCola]

Brees also scored 6 tds at 41 yrs old on the same D that made Mahomes look like trash.

Brees also had a higher QB rating than Mahomes did last year when he won the MVP.

Im just sick and tired of the disrespect Brees gets. Its appalling.

When it's a big game, the Saints lose ... but it's not Brees fault.

If the defense would stop choking on the last series of every big game, Brees would have multiple rings and a lot more high visibility wins. This Super Bowl is a prime example. The Chiefs were down, battled back, and when they needed one last defensive stop they got it. It seems whenever there's a big game and the Saints defense needs one more defensive stop, the secondary goes missing and some 40+ yard game killer happens.

 

[NOFALCONS10]

When it's a big game, the Saints lose ... but it's not Brees fault.

If the defense would stop choking on the last series of every big game, Brees would have multiple rings and a lot more high visibility wins. This Super Bowl is a prime example. The Chiefs were down, battled back, and when they needed one last defensive stop they got it. It seems whenever there's a big game and the Saints defense needs one more defensive stop, the secondary goes missing and some 40+ yard game killer happens.

One last point

2018 Brees 115 QB rating 74 % completion percentage

2018 Mahomes 105 QB rating 65% Completion percentage.

They gift the MVP to Mahomes.


The QB laurels are a joke at this point

Even PFF had Brees as the top QB last year.

Final list of PFF's highest-graded quarterbacks in the NFL in 2018 | NFL News, Rankings and Statistics | PFF

Pro Football Focus' final quarterback rankings for the 2018-19 NFL season.

www.pff.com