Dalton or Winston (1 Viewer)

[HogsNSaints]

Winston is infinitely more talented than Dalton.

And for what it’s worth, Winston is infinitely more talented than Teddy Bridgewater.

If this project works, Jameis Winston is a 10 year franchise QB. Teddy & Dalton are bridge QBs.

 

[English]

Dalton is a choker who can’t elevate his play to match the situation. Way more upside with Crabston and his new peepers

 

[Quiet Storm]

Honestly, what has Dalton done?

He's done nothing ever. Never cared for Winston but I'll take him over Dalton any day.

 

[Que Que 6]

If it was up to me I'd waited for Andy, but I know we probably wouldn't have accepted an cheap contract like Winston. I think Andy would have been a good replacement when Drew retired.

He looks/plays like he is 5 years OLDER than DB. Yeah, that would make sense. Go the opposite direction. LOL

 

[sainthood]

I would much rather have Winston. Dalton is 32. Winston is 26. Winston blows Dalton out of the water in talent and has shown no sign of a ceiling above mediocre. Winston shows a ceiling of Pat Mahomes type arm with a gunslinger penchant for interceptions that will either be solved or lead him to the ilk of Jeff George. The idea Winston would sign as a backup for such little pay. The man just got married to a woman from New Orleans and is exhibiting the kind of humility and mindset conducive to a transformative understanding of the game by watching Drew has so much more upside than you could ever contemplate with a player like Dalton.

 

[rail]

Username checks out.

 

[Seapea]

Why the hell does this thread exist?

Really y'all? You can't stand the thought of Jameis Winston being in NOLA so much that you have to look for alternative options even though the insurance QB need has been filled.

What's this really about, because I notice one difference between Jameis and Andy. ONE THING.

 

[St. Pike]

I wouldn't be surprise if he announces his retirement before long. Winston has potential to get better, Dalton you are racing against the clock that may have already passed.


----

 

[NatureBoy]

Winston

 

[Loose Cannon]

Do we want to make the playoffs and lose in the first round with the nice ginger boy next door, or do we want to take some shots that could make us a Super Bowl team?

I'd rather gamble with a Taysom Hill run offense than waste years wallowing in "pretty good" with Andy Dalton.

 

[60minutes]

Winston has greater upside and is younger. To me, this is not even close.

 

[Loose Cannon]

What's this really about, because I notice one difference between Jameis and Andy. ONE THING.

Ehh, there's a lot of this around, but I don't think it has much to do with this here. Winston has been a turnover machine and Dalton is more a safe, known quantity QB.

If you asked me to put $1,000 on which QB will be a good QB in the next few years, I'd very quickly put it on Dalton. If you asked me to put $1,000 on which QB could be a Super Bowl MVP in the future, it's going on Winston.

 

[Saint Greg]

What's this really about, because I notice one difference between Jameis and Andy. ONE THING.

Andy has red hair?

 

[Saint Kamara]

Honestly, what has Dalton done?

Well he won a playo........

Oh wait.

 

[StudioSaint]

Since 2011 he's one of 6 QB's to throw for over 30,000 yards, 200 TD's and win 70 games. The others are Brees, Big Ben, Rodgers, Brady and Matt Ryan.

and he has won . . . . what exactly?

I saw someone give this advice regarding keeping it real.

Let's keep everything real, the QB gets too much credit for wins and too much credit for losses. It's been that way from day one.