Draft Day Poll for Ellis and/or Dorsey (1 Viewer)

[whodat631]

If dorsey would not be from LSU how many of you would change your minds about him over ellis?

my thoughts exactly......

 

[whodat631]

Dorsey b/c he'd sell tickets!

So no other player drafted in the top 10 can sell tickets????

 

[VVextreme]

So no other player drafted in the top 10 can sell tickets????

Not like Dorsey could...

I say it's a coin flip. I don't think we are a player away from being in the super bowl, so the multiple picks might help us.

However a healthy Dorsey would be a thing to see. I don't know much about Ellis, but I'm guessing he would probably be the one available if we traded up. If he's close to Dorsey, that could be quite a sight.

However I know what a class act Dorsey is and his character, so I would probably trade to get Dorsey just cause he won every award known to man for his position and especially because of his leadership and impressive character traits. Let's face it, that kind of money will make a bunch of spoiled babies out of most 20ish yr olds. The Saints need that Dorsey type of player in the organization and not another NFL thug.

 

[Rich Jr]

No way, pick a #10 corner, they sign much cheaper.

The pick at #10 gets paid #10 money period.

 

[BIGRON]

There is no way I would trade up. Let the process play out and if the right defensive player is not there at #10 I would be glad to make the safe pick and take the OT Clady. Brees had too many passes batted down and our running game ( Bush ) can use some help up front which also helps the defense to stay on the bench.

 

[saintsfan15]

none i would just keep it like we are right now

 

[wbbigtymer]

Dorsey would be a no brainer over Ellis for any team, NEVER MIND ONE THAT PLAYS IN LOUISIANA.

 

[ScottRay504]

The pick at #10 gets paid #10 money period.

A cornerback and a defensive takle are in two entirely different pay scales.
You are going to pay more for a #10 DT than you are for a #10 CB, period.

Not to mention that the question was about trading up to get a defensive takle, which means picking at #3 or #4 (most likely Raiders' pick), which is even more money, period.

So we not only give up picks in the draft, we pay even more money for a position which we may or may not actually need, given the front four we currently have. Save the money for colston.... period.

 

[keefresh2]

Neither. Grab Rivers or a corner and then do what it takes to land Trevor Laws.

 

[Taceo]

If dorsey would not be from LSU how many of you would change your minds about him over ellis?

Dude, that card is sooo overplayed. Ellis played for a huge market media darling and Dorsey still managed to snag almost every defensive accolade this past year. Ellis wasn't even mentioned for half the things that Dorsey was up for. And let us not forget that, no matter how far down the totem pole he was, Dorsey was a Heisman candidate. So before you throw down your homer challenge, how about taking stock that nearly every fan base and draft analyst has Dorsey ranked higher than Ellis, not just the one that happens to be in LSU's state. Yes there are some people who have Ellis rated higher, but there are more that have Dorsey in the top 3.

 

[willkro]

I say either

 

[rickyjones]

Dorsey b/c he'd sell tickets!

With a 30,000+ season ticket waiting list I don't think Dorsey is the key.

 

[CitySaint]

How many Dt's picked in possibly the top 10 ever became Hall of Famers?