Ed Reed Or Charles Woodson? (1 Viewer)

[WestCoastFan]

I'm going for the trifecta. I want Reed, Sharper and Woodson. If they're willing to kick the tires on guys that are on the wrong side of thirty then grab all three and let them battle it out in TC with the young guys.

 

[bchevron]

Both.

It's hypothetical. Why not?

I like it. That would be sick to have Woodson and Reed back at safety.

 

[Maximaboi]

Reed all day everyday...

 

[MarkIngramfan16]

Reed all the way he has about 2 maybe 3 years left in the tank which is enough to get about 2 or three more super bowl rings

 

[ShahulX]

haha...im on the "both" wagon...

 

[ChadC]

You guys are crazy. Ed Reed is finished, he is a shell of his former self. Woodson is a dirty player and a cheap shot artist. No thanks to either.

 

[wnelson]

Both

 

[WhoDatfolife]

Both

 

[wnelson]

You guys are crazy. Ed Reed is finished, he is a shell of his former self. Woodson is a dirty player and a cheap shot artist. No thanks to either.

Both are better than Harper/Jenkins. Jesus the saints have more safety issues than BP

 

[Kurgan]

You guys are crazy. Ed Reed is finished, he is a shell of his former self. Woodson is a dirty player and a cheap shot artist. No thanks to either.

Even the shadow of reed would be better than the CRAP we have as starting safeties right now

 

[ChadC]

Even the shadow of reed would be better than the CRAP we have as starting safeties right now

Harper will thrive in Ryan's scheme. As far as Jenkins I'd rather move him to corner and start IAQ than blow money on Reed or Woodson.

 

[Kurgan]

Harper will thrive in Ryan's scheme. As far as Jenkins I'd rather move him to corner and start IAQ than blow money on Reed or Woodson.

So you would have preferred to keep kaevisharn/bullocks rather than signing sharper in 2009? It's not like jenkins (i'll give you the benefit of the doubt on harper) was better than that duo the past year, spagnuolo or no spagnuolo

 

[BigRaiderFan]

My idea is like your, but different:

Neither.

Aging vets are not the answer.

Darren Sharper was an aging vet. That worked out pretty well. 9 picks 3 TDs sounds like it worked out really well

 

[tak]

Hometown man Ed Reed.

 

[Joodas Avila]

Wow, thats a tricky one. I'll go with Ed, cause he's younger and doesnt have the injury history Woodson has.