Emmanuel Sanders TD Overturned - anyone see a replay? (1 Viewer)

[BiloxiSaint1]

I keep looking at that play and it looks like he clearly got in. Anyone see a replay of indisputable video evidence to overturn that TD call? I wish they would have shown us what they saw. Maybe they did and I just missed it. IDK.


EDITED @ 8:24 am 10-14-2020: @saintmike23 in post # 53 provided the below video look that I had not see when I was watching the ESPN broadcast. I still don't know if I just missed it or ESPN didn't show it in their coverage. Either way, this was the shot of indisputable video evidence I was looking for. Thanks @saintmike23 !

 

[Big_L]

I keep looking at that play and it looks like he clearly got in. Anyone see a replay of indisputable video evidence to overturn that TD call? I wish they would have shown us what they saw. Maybe they did an I just missed it. IDK.

I was thinking the same thing. Normally there would have been footage from the other side of the field. The ball is dark, so was the jersey. Hard to tell. I also thought without conclusive evidence an on the field call can't be overturned.

 

[syracuse saint]

I noted in another thread that he was untouched. They were focused on his knee when they should have looked at the obvious first. Watch it again and tell me who touched him

 

[Taker597]

It's funny... The rule is supposed to be undisputed evidence to overturn it. Yet, much like the Kamara TD it has changed to needing undisputed evidence to for it to stand.


Probably another petty decision from Review boothe

 

[BLUE_DOG_MAN]

To me it looked obvious it didn’t touch the goal line. BDM

 

[td2w]

Didn't you see the ball beyond his back through the X-Ray camera?

In all seriousness though, they should have showed the other angle.....

 

[syracuse saint]

Al Riveron will use every opportunity possible to get back at CSP. Think about when he stopped the game to review ball spot which gave the Chargers time to catch their breath and plan two plays with only one time out left

 

[UFCSaint]

I keep looking at that play and it looks like he clearly got in. Anyone see a replay of indisputable video evidence to overturn that TD call? I wish they would have shown us what they saw. Maybe they did and I just missed it. IDK.

That's the play I was referring to in the other thread. Couldn't remember the player. Looked like a clear TD to me. They reviewed and I was like...well this is a waste. Then inexplicably overturned it. I waited to see the replay...they looked like they were going to...then never showed it.

 

[NativeFan]

They showed the replay during the game and to me it wasn't even close. That wasn't a touchdown.

 

[td2w]

They showed the replay during the game and to me it wasn't even close. That wasn't a touchdown.

It was impossible to see the ball on that replay. You saw just the tip but it's not clear evidence..

 

[BreesHOF2024]

I also remember them giving the Chargers a free 2 minutes on their last drive to review an obvious spot which gave them time to draw up several plays in advance.

 

[SaintsFanInLA]

The ball was short of the goal line when his knee touched but I am not sure that HE was touched.

 

[Saint Taysom]

This thread is useless w/out a video clip of the play

 

[guidomerkinsrules]

I also remember them giving the Chargers a free 2 minutes on their last drive to review an obvious spot which gave them time to draw up several plays in advance.

that's the one that got me
an absolutely useless and uncalled for stoppage

 

[UFCSaint]

Play is at 8:35. I still don't see how that was overturned.