guarding the potatoes
VIP Subscribing Member
Diamond VIP Contributor
- Aug 9, 2004
- Reaction score
- Mt. Pleasant, SC
Ha, yes, I saw that.
As with any other new & good band that comes on the music scene, most people can't help but to think about who they compare to in sound and style. When a group can rightly be compared to one of the most incredible sounds in rock history, they can find the road very challenging because the comparing never stops.
Some purists believe that musical art means never 'imitating' the blasts of the past. But personally I know the sound(s) that I like, and it doesn't matter to me who makes those sounds or when they come on the scene. I will be drawn to that sound just as I did the very first time I heard Led Zeppelin's first album.
From what I hear in these kids, they could make a good living even if they turned themselves into a Zep tribute band. But hopefully they won't be ignored for making songs that sound a lot like the mighty LZ.
If it sounds like real classic rock... I'm listening!
This band may claim that they aren't trying to emulate Zeppelin, but what I see gives the impression that they practiced for years to pull off a lot of LZ's moves and sound. Yet they do it so naturally and effortlessly. And the singer has the perfect combination of bluesy whine and raw power in his vocal skills to pull off an authentic Plant sound, even though his choreography is a bit 'stiffer'.
It wouldn't bother me one bit if the sound comes off as 'innovative' to today's generation of kids who think that much of what's playing today is real music. Good bands like this one could start a revival that might make 'new' music enjoyable to listen to. Right now all I can deal with is classic rock radio stations.But we're now almost 50 years from the release of Led Zeppelin. Is it gimmick or is it homage? Either way, like you said, if it sounds good - if they pull it off - then it's enjoyable IMO.
Meh.. have heard better HS bands than them.
What's special? That they sound like LZ?
Also, was this at a freaking talent show or something? Why is everyone in the crowd sitting?
Just for the record, I didn't say they sound just like, merely stated sound like, as in it has a ring to it.it gets old to see the "oh they sound just like Zeppelin".
Just for the record, I didn't say they sound just like, merely stated sound like, as in it has a ring to it.
I don't know about them being "talented". They play and sound like a decent HS band, but that's it.
As for your last statements about Page and Bonham, I'll just let it go because you are blinded by your LZ colored glasses
Y'all damn well know there were guys that were your age now in 1967-1970 that expressed similar sentiment about Zep: "They are bowlderizing the sound of the Delta Blues legends...so little craftsmanship and no subtlety...too much vamping and preening by the singer...etc. etc."But they don't. The clip I linked to was Zeppelin when Plant and Bonham were 20/21 years old. Page and Jones were what 23? Not much of an age difference.
As a Zeppelin fan, it gets old to see the "oh they sound just like Zeppelin". Here's some advice. Be yourself. These kids have spent a great amount of time copying a great group. But, that is all it is. They all seem talented, but they need to work it to their own sound. That combo was a one of a kind. How many Page's are there? There is only 1 other person who can drum as good as, or better than in the style of John Bonham and that's his son Jason who in my opinion is better than his dad.
These guys need to listen to Dave Grohl on how to form and develop a band
I love this line. Its important, and it really accentuates the awesomeness of music. My, lets call it, "gateway" band was the Dixie Dregs, through them I grew an appreciation of bluegrass and baroque/flamenco music that I never would have gained. They really opened up new musical worlds for me. Steely Dan did as well (jazz)....To me that is the definition of greatness...a band that makes you appreciate not just their music but where it came from....As an average white teenager, I did not come to Zeppelin through the Delta Blues, but rather came to Delta Blues through Zeppelin. What seems like stealing or copying or mimicry in the moment can later take on significance as a path to the source material for new listeners, especially with the streaming economy we have now.