guarding the potatoes
VIP Subscribing Member
Diamond VIP Contributor
- Aug 9, 2004
- Reaction score
- Mt. Pleasant, SC
Oasis=Beatles.Well, Rush’s drummer passed away a little over a year ago (glioblastoma). And, Zeppelin’s drummer passed away decades ago (apparent substance abuse). I think I rememberZeppelin using Bonham’s son, Jason, here and there and then he went on to form some “Led Zeppelin Experience” project band. Was never a fan of the original Zeppelin, so I didn’t bother to dig further.
Could be worse I suppose. GVF could be trying to emulate the Beatles or the Stones...
I think it’s ironic that people have hang ups about GVF because they sound like Zeppelin. Do people not realize that Led Zeppelin was copying American blues musicians when they first started out? Robert Plant and Jimmy Page have admitted that they “borrowed“ from early American blues singers and guitar players.
Folks: Led Zeppelin is not the root of rock n roll. Everybody borrows from every one else. That’s been going on since the beginning of time.
Excellent post! Very well said.
These issues can't be ignored or overlooked as mesmerizing, powerful, visually and musically dynamic Led Zeppelin were for 12 years as one of the most influential, most successful rock bands in the 1970's and how they(along moreso with Black Sabbath) helped popularize and create this rock sub genre we now call heavy metal. How many times has Pink Floyd or the Who ever been accused or taken to court for supposedly stealing, plagiarizing other rock bands melodies, basic and major chords, choruses, or recording Willie Dixon, or Bo Diddley's old songs without giving them a writer's credit on the album sleeves or being sued and forced to issue them credits on later pressings of the album?
- Borrowing music, lyrics, and songs from acoustic, Mississippi Delta blues musicians would be one acceptable term in how Zeppelin co-opted their style into their own unique sound, and legacy. There are other terms like plagiarism, and stealing and forgetting/neglecting to credit many of these same Delta musicians for using their songs. I mean, how many times were Zep taken to court during the band's existence during the 1970's and up to the present day for copyright infringements, or failing to credit musicians for covering or using part of their lyrics, or music in their own songs, especially when it came time to issuing the band's box sets?
The only rock band Pete Townsend has admitted he may have subconsciously been influenced by in terms of writing songs, or creating an edgier, aggressive sound were the Kinks. Ray and Dave Davies have even gone on record multiple times saying they believed or have long suspected Townsend's inspiration for writing Tommy was that the Kinks were writing a rock opera, Arthur and the Decline and Fall of the British Empire, around the same time.
Wow I don’t know where I was at the beginning of this thread but that is probably the best R Plant emulation I have ever heard.
the open of the second song posted “highway” sounds just like Plant through parts of While Lotta Love.
that is pretty high praise considering his legend. But high road was the only way to go. You seem petty otherwise and it is a high form of flattery.Robert Plant has opened up about his feelings toward Greta Van Fleet, a hard rock band often accused of copying Led Zeppelin.www.cheatsheet.com
I'm not disagreeing with you. But I don't know anyone that would argue that Led Zep were the "originators" of rock.Good one. But I think ole Rocky would’ve thrown in the towel on this debate too!
Agreed, never been a fan of Elvis. But one of my best friends who is actually a really talented guitarist, loves him and believes he started it all....I don't know why he believes this...