Not sure why you'd compare 2 songs that couldn't be more different. I really like both of them. But they evoke much different feelings when listening to them. I wouldn't take one over the other. They're both great.
This was a thread on discussing who the greatest band is. I thought it would be a great question to understand where people's preferences are. Considering the question was directed to someone who said, Prince was the best band, just wanted to see, which water he prefers to drink.
It wouldn't take me two seconds to decide which song is better. Not sure I can totally relate to your answer, but thanks for the response. I honestly would figure you would pick the Metallica song from your previous responses, so this shocked me a little.