If you could only choose one. Would you take a healthy Joe Horn or Roman Harper? (1 Viewer)

[ChopperSaint]

Which one of these 2 players do you think we miss the most?

 

[easye98]

Give me Harper, we need all the help we can get in the secondary.

 

[Loose Cannon]

Harper, no doubt. Sorry Joe.

 

[THAJCODE]

 

[Euthan]

yeah... Harper would be big... especially if he'd accumilated all the experiance from these games he's missed...

 

[LSSpam]

Joe Horn. I think we've adjusted with Bellamy to Harper being out. I have a feeling Joe's experience will weigh extremely heavy in the postseason.

And yes, this largely based on gut feeling and not the results of the past season.

 

[p0pe]

Harper... I love Joe but I'm more concerned about our defense.

 

[srenner]

Second round versus Philly/Seattle/Dallas = Harper
Championship round versus Chicago = Horn

 

[Professor]

We need the help on defense more than offense. Horn's great and a plus to the team, but others have picked up the slack admirably.

 

[JOElittleBIGhorn]

I'd take Joe for the playoffs. Experience counts in the post season and Roman has close to none.

 

[WeatherNLU]

Joe Horn, and not because Harper doesn't maybe mean more from a talent perspective. Horn brings exactly what this team needs during the playoffs........a team leader.

 

[Craig Walker]

I'm going to say Joe. I'm praying one of our 'dropsey' WRs doesn't cost us in the playoffs. I know Joe has dropped a few too, but I just feel that Joe has a HUGE play in him to get us where we want to go.

 

[Saint DoubleL]

Horn everyday of the week and twice on sunday!

 

[Derilicte]

That's a tough question. I think I would take Horn because of the leadership. And yes I know Brees is the leader and so is Dulemus, but I think Joe Horn brings a little swagger to the team when he's playing. Harper was a great player while he was healthy and I would love to have him back, but Bellamy and Stoutmire have filled in nicely. Plus he's just a rookie