Preseason QB Battle (1 Viewer)

[rsmith2783]

Last year I posted a battle thread on Teddy vs Taysom in preseason. It was close, but Taysom came out the winner. This year I was going to do a Teddy vs Jameis Winston, but I figured that it's not going to be fair considering that Taysom has been with the team 3 years now.

So to keep it fair, it's Jameis vs Tommy. I'm rolling with Tommy on this one.
Who do you have winning the preseason battle?

 

[meily]

What?

 

[DerrickB]

Last year I posted a battle thread on Teddy vs Taysom in preseason. It was close, but Taysom came out the winner. This year I was going to do a Teddy vs Jameis Winston, but I figured that it's not going to be fair considering that Taysom has been with the team 3 years now.

So to keep it fair, it's Jameis vs Tommy. I'm rolling with Tommy on this one.
Who do you have winning the preseason battle?

 

[Seapea]

Former first round pick who has passed for over 5,000 yards already in his career vs. a deep seventh round Taysom Hill prototype who's unproven and generally unknown by everyone else.

Hmmmmmm.

 

[Rdanderson91]

This ain’t it chief

 

[t-rex23]

My man... Tommy Stevens is in competition with Hardee, Gray, Washington

Not Jameis

 

[DerrickB]

My man... Tommy Stevens is in competition with Hardee, Gray, Washington

Not Jameis

That sounds more like it.

 

[Optimus Prime]

My man... Tommy Stevens is in competition with Hardee, Gray, Washington

Not Jameis

I read this as he’s in competition with Hardee, Washington

As in, that’s the name of the hometown he’ll be returning to if he gets cut

 

[saintsmarchin]

Jameis is gonna be the next starting QB of the Saints. I'm sorry to burst your bubbles.

 

[saint_drago]

As absurd as this poll and discussion is, I'd much rather be talking Winston vs Stevens as opposed to Brees vs Jenkins.

A few threads have popped up over the past few days talking about actual football and it's been refreshing. So yeah, I'm gonna go with Winston on this one. He could win by default because Stevens might not even make the roster.

 

[SweetT]

He don’t know no better

 

[So_$@int Silly]

Lol

 

[parlorcitysaint]

This year I was going to do a Teddy vs Jameis Winston, but I figured that it's not going to be fair considering that Taysom has been with the team 3 years now.

You DO know that Teddy is in carolina now, don't you?

 

[Saintaholik]

Last year I posted a battle thread on Teddy vs Taysom in preseason. It was close, but Taysom came out the winner. This year I was going to do a Teddy vs Jameis Winston, but I figured that it's not going to be fair considering that Taysom has been with the team 3 years now.

So to keep it fair, it's Jameis vs Tommy. I'm rolling with Tommy on this one.
Who do you have winning the preseason battle?

Your rolling with Tommy?? Hey I guess your gonna look like a freaking genius if it works out that way

 

[SammyIsGod]

At least we got a new thread to look at!

Not really a debate on paper. I don't think we brought Crablegs in to get beat by a flyer 7th round pick. I guess stranger things have happened, but I don't see it. I knew nothing about Tommy going in, and from what I read we only drafted him to screw over a division rival. Not saying Sean didn't like something about him, which was all the hoopla about early undrafted contracts and what not, but a trio of Drew, Crablegs, and Taysom is something I don't think any team has at the QB position.