Pro Bowl Ballots - Who did you vote for? (1 Viewer)

[shrike3000]

Here is my final Pro Bowl votes. I am curious to see others.

AFC QB -
P. Manning
C. Palmer
P. Rivers

NFC QB -
D. Brees
M. Bulger
E. Manning

AFC RB -
L. Johnson
W. Parker
L. Tomlinson

NFC RB -
T. Barber
F. Gore
S. Jackson

AFC WR -
M. Harrison
A. Johnson
C. Johnson
R. Wayne

NFC WR -
M. Colston
D. Driver
S. Smith
T. Holt

AFC FB -
L. Neal

NFC FB -
M. Karney

AFC TE -
A. Gates
T. Gonzalez

NFC TE -
C. Cooley
A. Crumpler

AFC K -
N. Kaeding

NFC K -
R. Gould

AFC P -
C. Hentrich

NFC P -
M. McBriar

AFC G -
M. Goff
V. Manuwai
J. Bell

NFC G -
R. Brown
J. Evans
S. Hutchinson

AFC T -
M. Light
M. McNeil
T. Glenn

NFC T -
J. Brown
B. McKinnie
J. Runyan

AFC C -
J. Saturday
K. Mawae

NFC C -
J. Faine
O. Kreutz

AFC CB -
C. Bailey
R. Mathis
A. Samuel

NFC CB -
R. Barber
T. Newman
L. Sheppard

AFC SS -
T. Polamalu

NFC SS -
A. Wilson

AFC FS -
K. Rhodes

NFC FS -
D. Smith

AFC DE -
L. Castillo
A. Schobel
J. Taylor

NFC DE -
A. Kampman
J. Peppers
W. Smith

AFC ILB -
B. Scott
D. Ryans

NFC ILB -
N. Barnett
B. Urlacher

AFC OLB -
A. Thomas
K. Bullock

NFC OLB -
L. Briggs
J. Peterson

AFC DT -
T. Pryce
J. Williams

NFC DT -
K. Jenkins
K. Williams

AFC KR -
P. Jones

NFC KR -
D. Hester

AFC ST -
Y. Bell

NFC ST -
S. Gleason

 

[LSSpam]

Straight Saints players. If the NFL is going to treat the fan vote as a ridiculous farce (like opening up fan voting as early as Week 6, not even giving lip service to "one fan, one vote", etc) then I will too.

If I had to pick seriously, ummmm

NFC
QB - D. Brees, M. Bulger, E. Manning (explanation- McNabb got hurt, otherwise he's #2. If McNabb can't get in because he got hurt, Romo doesn't get in because he's played as many games as McNabb. And without Romo and McNabb, there's no legitimate #3. Eli gets in because the NFC has crappy QBs)
RB - T. Barbar, F. Gore, S. Jackson
FB - M. Karney (only NFC FB i've paid attention too )
WR - S, Smith, T. Holt, R. Williams, D. Driver
TE - A. Crumpler, J. Shockey
T - B. McKinnie, J. Brown, W. Jones (Walter Jones probably doesn't deserve it, he hasn't been great this year, but no one else in the NFC deserves it either.)
G - C. Snee, S. Hutchinson, A. Timmerman
C - J. Faine, O. Kreutz



DE - J. Peppers, C. Grant, A. Kampman (Kampman's dropped off but Strahan got hurt)
DT - P. Williams, T. Harris (only recently got hurt)
OLB - D. Ware, J. Peterson (even though we trashed Ware last week)
ILB - B. Urlacher, A. Pierce
CB - T. Newman, M. McKenzie, L. Sheppard
FS - K. Hamlin
SS - D. Sharper

KR - D. Hester
ST - S. Gleason

 

[meily]

QB: Brees, Bulger, Manning
RB: Gore, Duece, Barber
FB: Karney
WR: Colston, R.Williams, Smith, Holt
TE: Shockey, Smith
OL: J.Brown, Walter, Evans, Hutchinson, Faine, Kruetz
DE: W.Smith, C.Grant,J.Peppers, Kampman
DT: H.Thomas, C.Redding, Glover
LB: Urlacher, Trotter, Biggs, Fujita
CB: M.McKenzie, Newman, Hall
FS:?
SS: R.WIlliams

Punter: Weatherford
Kicker: Gould
KR/PR: Hester
ST: Gleason

 

[shrike3000]

Yeah Manning really gets in as the best of the worst. Mcnabb if he was healthy. I also would have voted for Tommie Harris if he was healthy, just not sure if injured players can even go. I left off Roy Williams to put in Colston, I didnt like doing it because Roy Williams has had an amazing year but I have a feeling Colston will be big in these final 3 games.

 

[DieselNutz]

Only vote for the Saints players, when you vote for other players it decreases the chances of the Saints player making the Pro Bowl.

 

[shrike3000]

I more meant it as a theoretical serious vote. I know the fan vote is really pretty much a joke. But if you had to choose who you thought the actual pro bowl players should be without being a homer who would you vote for?

 

[boutrous]

I voted for the entire Saints' and Chargers' O-Lines, FBs, RBs and QBs.

I didn't vote for Holt... he was inconsistant at best this year. 3 big games and a LOT of small ones.

 

[LSSpam]

Yeah Manning really gets in as the best of the worst. Mcnabb if he was healthy. I also would have voted for Tommie Harris if he was healthy, just not sure if injured players can even go. I left off Roy Williams to put in Colston, I didnt like doing it because Roy Williams has had an amazing year but I have a feeling Colston will be big in these final 3 games.

Well, I did it basically on the past 13 weeks. T. Harris hasn't missed many games yet so he still gets in. No idea if he'd actually go or not. And I think Colston would reinterject himself into the debate the final 3 games, but the voting ends Friday and he missed to many games out of what you have to judge by.

Honestly I don't know why they don't just do the votes all during the postseason AFTER the season is over, including the fan vote. At least then the Pro Bowl might have some semblance of being legitimate.