Schein and Hasselbeck sirius ranked NFC south (2 Viewers)

[Complex Kid]

Dan Marino regretting not winning a Super Bowl is not the same as him saying any one who has won a Super Bowl is better than him.

 

[BlackNGoldblood]

Regrets don't directly correlate to the quality of player. Marino may regret not winning a Super Bowl, he's still better then Trent Dilfer. On this board we refer to your post as "crawfishing"

I can't believe that a who-is-better-argument, Dilfer or Marino, is actually a discussion on this forum.

 

[Saints382]

I can't believe that a who-is-better-argument, Dilfer or Marino, is actually a discussion on this forum.

Sorta starting to be like the Falclowns MB...

"Joey Harrington is better then Peyton Manning" and "Keith Brooking is better then Ray Lewis"...

That's true... some of those "fans" did debate about that on that forum. No lies.

 

[basilisk]

hahahaha, you seriously think eli is better than brees? if brees replaced eli in that game he wouldve easily won it

maybe brees is better than eli, but if you asked 32 GMs who they'd take, brees or eli, what do you think the majority answer would be? yes, *we* like brees but i'd guess most teams would take eli

 

[BoNcHiE]

maybe brees is better than eli, but if you asked 32 GMs who they'd take, brees or eli, what do you think the majority answer would be? yes, *we* like brees but i'd guess most teams would take eli

No, most GMs wouldn't take a QB, who posted a 73 rating last year, and has never been much more then average and any point, over a guy like Brees who is only 29. The only thing Eli has going for him is his age.

 

[bushleague]

a week division? going back to 2000 which NFC division has had the most reps in the championship game? same question for Superbowl appearences?

 

[duckjr78]

a week division? going back to 2000 which NFC division has had the most reps in the championship game? same question for Superbowl appearences?

Best post on this thread yet.

 

[SuJaguar00]

maybe brees is better than eli, but if you asked 32 GMs who they'd take, brees or eli, what do you think the majority answer would be? yes, *we* like brees but i'd guess most teams would take eli

Wait.....what? This has to be some sort of sick joke. A 5 week stretch of good football and winning a Super Bowl does not trump the inconsistent play that plagued Eli's career. Now, if Eli picks up in '08 where he left off '07 and continues to play well than maybe this would make sense (a big maybe). Right now, arguments like that are just not factually based. Sorry.....

 

[bushleague]

how do you get off the practice squad?

 

[SaintsFanatic]

LoL

You're right - Eli has won a Super Bowl.

Nice argument.

Ask any coach and any player in the league who they would rather have as QB. I guarantee 100% of them would say Brees over Eli.

 

[Chinese bandits]

I love these kinds of replies because they always involve some kind of rationalization. Eli has done it, Brees hasn't.

Proof = in pudding.

with this inference, Dilfer > Marino ?!