Offline
I personally think that this common conversational question is annoying and should be avoided. At best, it demonstrates a lack of conversational skill and at worst is intrusive. There are so many interesting things to talk about - yet people often jump to this question when talking to someone new. In fact, some people even seem to have a compulsion to ask it.
I'm certainly not suggesting that it has no place. Sometimes it may come up if someone volunteers an story arising from their work and it may then be perfectly natural to inquire. But as an ice-breaker, I think it's weak.
I think that most of us prefer not to talk about work in our social time. Plus, it can be uncomfortable if someone is unemployed or self-conscious about their job. This could even lead to unnecessary judgments about people that have no place in social conversation IMO.
I just think it's bad form and says to the other person "I got nothing else interesting to say to you except to ask you about one of the things in your life that you'd probably choose not to do if you had a choice."
I'm certainly not suggesting that it has no place. Sometimes it may come up if someone volunteers an story arising from their work and it may then be perfectly natural to inquire. But as an ice-breaker, I think it's weak.
I think that most of us prefer not to talk about work in our social time. Plus, it can be uncomfortable if someone is unemployed or self-conscious about their job. This could even lead to unnecessary judgments about people that have no place in social conversation IMO.
I just think it's bad form and says to the other person "I got nothing else interesting to say to you except to ask you about one of the things in your life that you'd probably choose not to do if you had a choice."