Christian McCaffrey or Alvin Kamara ???

Dome50 said
I kind of compare the Kamara vs. McCaffrey debate to the JJ Watt vs. Cam Jordan debate.

Both sets of players were drafted the same year and have similar career stats. However, they got those stats differently. Watt/McCaffrey had a handful of MONSTER seasons racking up HUGE stats but lost big chunks of seasons due to injury. Kamara and Jordan have had very consistent probowl caliber seasons with few games lost to injury. That consistency is reflected in the probowls vs. all pro awards the players have received. Kamara/Jordan have more probowls but McCaffrey/Watt have more All Pros. Frankly, at this stage, I would take my boys Kamara/Jordan due to consistency and availability.

Comparisons here:

https://stathead.com/football/versu...ource=pfr&utm_medium=sr_xsite&utm_id=WattJ.00
https://stathead.com/football/versu...ource=pfr&utm_medium=sr_xsite&utm_id=McCaCh01

Yeah, I posted this in January and the idea is once again proving true this season. Kamara is the model of consistency whereas CMC has the absolutely monster All-Pro seasons and then follows them up with injury wash out seasons. I'm taking Kamara and his consistency/availability all day every day. Think that consistency also resulted in Jordan/Kamara playing their entire careers for one team (hope that stays true) and Watt/CMC did not.