Too many good safeties, What to do, Who to Trade? (1 Viewer)

[TruSaint]

Despite what many think, roman harper has been very good this year, he has made great stops in the run and had great coverage on tons of plays 1 on 1, i have been impressed, there is no safety who is perfect but after he has upgraded his coverage skills which have been obvious to me roman is a baller. One of the top 5 best SS in the league, and im a harper hater btw, but ive seen him improve.


Jenkins who would thought would be a great center field is too aggressive for the FS position, but he does play very good man D, which now that i think about it is obvious since he was a lockdown corner in college. his best position would be SS in my opinion. Jenkins would be a good SS since he can play great man D on TE's and RB's and can be used aggresively in flat and hook zone coverage.

Quddus when on the field has looked awesome, he has played very good man on man, zone, and run support, he is big, 6"3, and fast, 4.39 speed and he lays the wood and shows incredible insincts. But if u dont wanna go by how he has looked on the field statistically i think he is tied for the 2nd best efficiency rate in the league forcing an insane qb to wr incompletion rate.

My question is would you:
1. Move jenkins to CB, Quddus to FS, leave roman at SS
2. Move Quddus to FS, Trade Jenkins
3. Move Jenkins to SS, Quddus to FS, trade roman

I personally believe 1 is the best option, it puts out better players on the field, jenkins is better than corey white or patrick at corner and can hold up in the run game, and it also saves us a draft pick from drafting another cb, u now need 4 good cbs in the nfl, also greer is aging so we will need to draft a high profile cb soon to replace him i'd love to get dee milliner but we need pass rush help

 

[saints2k8]

Despite what many think, roman harper has been very good this year, he has made great stops in the run and had great coverage on tons of plays 1 on 1, i have been impressed, there is no safety who is perfect but after he has upgraded his coverage skills which have been obvious to me roman is a baller. One of the top 5 best SS in the league, and im a harper hater btw, but ive seen him improve.


Jenkins who would thought would be a great center field is too aggressive for the FS position, but he does play very good man D, which now that i think about it is obvious since he was a lockdown corner in college. his best position would be SS in my opinion. Jenkins would be a good SS since he can play great man D on TE's and RB's and can be used aggresively in flat and hook zone coverage.

Quddus when on the field has looked awesome, he has played very good man on man, zone, and run support, he is big, 6"3, and fast, 4.39 speed and he lays the wood and shows incredible insincts. But if u dont wanna go by how he has looked on the field statistically i think he is tied for the 2nd best efficiency rate in the league forcing an insane qb to wr incompletion rate.

My question is would you:
1. Move jenkins to CB, Quddus to FS, leave roman at SS
2. Move Quddus to FS, Trade Jenkins
3. Move Jenkins to SS, Quddus to FS, trade roman

I personally believe 1 is the best option, it puts out better players on the field, jenkins is better than corey white or patrick at corner and can hold up in the run game, and it also saves us a draft pick from drafting another cb, u now need 4 good cbs in the nfl, also greer is aging so we will need to draft a high profile cb soon to replace him i'd love to get dee milliner but we need pass rush help

I like #1

Jenkins was solid as a CB/nickel + he was a beast on special teams

 

[ktgoti]

#1 is probably the most likely scenario. I dont see anyone trading for neither Harper or Jenkins.

 

[bornnraisedwhodat]

Harper has the biggest salary so trade him.

I love Harper, he is a great Saint and personality on our team, but he is also limited in what he can do for the amount we are paying him. I would like to see Isa Abdul put full time at FS and Jenkins moved to SS, or nickel, and Corey White moved to SS, or draft a guy.

Question is who would give up a pick for a limited aging SS?

 

[SaintSeb]

I like Quddus at FS. He punishes people back there.

 

[TruSaint]

like i said i think option 1 is best, is fills 2 voids, getting a true FS back there and improving our CB depth, win/win

 

[1badsailor]

#1 is probably the most likely scenario. I dont see anyone trading for neither Harper or Jenkins.

Harper certainly has trade value you send that boy to let's say the ravens where the already have reed or the chiefs where they have berry.. and allow him to just crush folks and those defenses immediately get better. Harper gets ragged arund here but there aren't many ss in the league that can play with with his intensity and leadership.. the boy is a gamer.. but he is a small fast lb not a db imo

 

[TruSaint]

Harper certainly has trade value you send that boy to let's say the ravens where the already have reed or the chiefs where they have berry.. and allow him to just crush folks and those defenses immediately get better. Harper gets ragged arund here but there aren't many ss in the league that can play with with his intensity and leadership.. the boy is a gamer.. but he is a small fast lb not a db imo

exactly, on a team with good CBs and a good coverage FS, roman would be a monster at safety, like for the ravens or cowboys, beast

 

[SaintsJunkie]

we just need some play making dbs and OLBs, and maybe a DE

 

[theicebox]

Some teams adjust accordingly to there strenths.
IAQ would def. be better at safety than Jenkins.
Jenkins is a great corner/nickle.
I dont know why the saints dont move him again. He has worked but hasnt panned out like we thought at safety.

 

[Swampy Saint]

Harper has the biggest salary so trade him.

I love Harper, he is a great Saint and personality on our team, but he is also limited in what he can do for the amount we are paying him. I would like to see Isa Abdul put full time at FS and Jenkins moved to SS, or nickel, and Corey White moved to SS, or draft a guy.

Question is who would give up a pick for a limited aging SS?

Harper is a stud. We would be much worse without him. No way they trade him. Restructure his contract? I'd buy that.

 

[TheRealJRad]

Some teams adjust accordingly to there strenths.
IAQ would def. be better at safety than Jenkins.
Jenkins is a great corner/nickle.
I dont know why the saints dont move him again. He has worked but hasnt panned out like we thought at safety.

We're running hot as a team, and changing guys around mid-season is risky, imo.

 

[SaintsFanatic]

does everyone saying move Jenkins to CB have amnesia?

 

[Twyst]

Give Roman some hgh and move him to OLB

 

[theicebox]

does everyone saying move Jenkins to CB have amnesia?

Please. Tell us.
I think his best suite is SS. But harpers not going anywhere.