I had Google Gemini create a mock for the Saints.

[jcollins9]

I asked for a trade DOWN in the first. Here it is:

Trade: The New Orleans Saints (Pick 9) trade their first-round pick to the Philadelphia Eagles (Pick 22) for:

• Eagles' 2025 First-Round Pick (Pick 22)
• Eagles' 2025 Second-Round Pick (Pick 54)
• Eagles' 2025 Sixth-Round Pick (Pick 190)

New Orleans Saints 2025 Mock Draft (Post-Trade Down):

Round 1, Pick 22: Princely Umanmielen, EDGE, Florida

• Analysis: An explosive and athletic edge rusher with the potential to develop into a consistent pass-rushing threat. Umanmielen has shown flashes of dominance and fits the profile of what the Saints need on the defensive line.

Round 2, Pick 40: Emeka Egbuka, WR, Ohio State

• Analysis: A highly skilled and polished wide receiver with excellent route-running ability and reliable hands. Egbuka would provide a strong complement to Chris Olave and give the Saints a dependable target in the passing game.

Round 2, Pick 54 (via PHI): Graham Barton, OT/OG, Duke

• Analysis: A versatile offensive lineman who has experience playing both tackle and guard at a high level. Barton's athleticism and football IQ would be a valuable addition to the Saints' offensive line, providing flexibility and potential as a long-term starter.

Round 3, Pick 71: Tyleik Williams, DT, Ohio State

• Analysis: A disruptive interior defensive lineman with the ability to generate pressure and be stout against the run. Williams would bolster the Saints' defensive tackle rotation and provide valuable interior push.

Round 3, Pick 93 (via DEN): Quinshon Judkins, RB, Ohio State

• Analysis: A powerful and productive running back with excellent vision and the ability to break tackles. Judkins could provide a strong running game presence for the Saints and potentially be the future of the position.

Round 4, Pick 111: Benjamin Morrison, CB, Michigan

• Analysis: A talented cornerback with good size and ball skills. Morrison has shown the potential to be a solid cover corner and would add valuable depth and competition to the Saints' secondary.

Round 6, Pick 185: Ja'Tavion Sanders, TE, Texas:

• Analysis: Sanders is an athletic and receiving-oriented tight end with good size and hands. While Juwan Johnson is a capable receiving tight end, Sanders offers a different level of potential as a pass-catching threat and could develop into a significant weapon in the Saints' offense. This adds a dynamic element to their tight end room.

Round 6, Pick 190 (via PHI): Malaki Starks, S, Georgia

• Analysis: An athletic and instinctive safety with good range and coverage ability. Starks has the potential to develop into a quality starter in the NFL and would add depth to the Saints' secondary.

Round 7, Pick 220: Christian Mahogany, OG, Boston College

• Analysis: A strong and physical interior offensive lineman who could provide valuable depth and potentially develop into a starter at guard.

What do you think?

 

[sipsey37]

I did the same think with grok

Creating a "perfect" New Orleans Saints mock draft for the 2025 NFL Draft depends on the team's current needs, draft position, and available talent as of March 26, 2025. The Saints are in a transitional phase with a new head coach, Kellen Moore, and significant salary cap challenges, limiting their free agency flexibility. They need to address key positions like edge rusher, offensive line, wide receiver, and potentially quarterback, while building a foundation for the future. Based on current roster gaps, expert analyses, and draft projections, here’s a 7-round mock draft tailored to maximize immediate impact and long-term potential. I’ll assume the Saints hold the No. 9 overall pick, as projected in many mocks, and include realistic additional picks based on their current draft capital and past trades (e.g., extra picks from the Marshon Lattimore trade).

---

### New Orleans Saints 2025 Mock Draft

#### Round 1, Pick 9: Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Arizona
- **Why:** The Saints offense needs a dynamic playmaker to complement Chris Olave and open up Kellen Moore’s playbook. Derek Carr or a future QB would benefit from a high-upside target. McMillan, at 6’5” and 212 lbs, is a big-bodied receiver with elite contested-catch ability and surprising agility. Experts like Canal Street Chronicles’ Yaccarino call him “the best pure receiver in the draft,” capable of being a true WR1. With Michael Thomas gone and the receiver room thin beyond Olave, McMillan fills a glaring need and provides a red-zone threat.
- **Fit:** His versatility to play outside or in the slot aligns with Moore’s creative offensive schemes, giving the Saints a cornerstone piece.

#### Round 2, Pick 40: Nic Scourton, EDGE, Texas A&M
- **Why:** The Saints’ pass rush is aging and depleted. Cameron Jordan is 36, Chase Young is a free agent, and Payton Turner hasn’t panned out. Scourton offers a high-ceiling replacement with power and athleticism. His Texas A&M tape shows a knack for bull-rushing linemen, and his 2024 stats (e.g., pressures and sacks) make him a Day 2 steal. FanSided mocks highlight his “real power at the point of attack,” ideal for replacing Jordan’s presence.
- **Fit:** Scourton can start early, providing a two-way edge defender to bolster a defense that ranks near the bottom in total yards allowed.

#### Round 3, Pick 71: Mason Taylor, TE, LSU
- **Why:** The tight end position is a weak spot with Juwan Johnson’s free agency looming and Foster Moreau’s contract expiring soon. Taylor, a local LSU product, brings size (6’5”, 255 lbs) and reliable hands, making him a safety blanket for the QB. FanSided notes his rise after a strong combine, projecting him as a “power slot option.” He’s not elite yet but has starter potential.
- **Fit:** Moore’s offense thrives with versatile tight ends, and Taylor’s blocking and receiving skills add balance to the attack.

#### Round 3, Pick 90 (via trade, e.g., Lattimore deal): Will Campbell, OT, LSU
- **Why:** The offensive line needs reinforcement, especially at tackle, where Trevor Penning has struggled (PFF grade 61.6) and Ryan Ramczyk’s health is uncertain. Campbell, another LSU star, offers agility and balance despite shorter arms (32⅝ inches). Field Yates praises his “best footwork of any offensive lineman in the class,” projecting him as a potential guard or tackle. He’s a high-value pick here.
- **Fit:** Campbell could compete at right tackle or slide inside, protecting Carr and boosting the run game for Alvin Kamara.

#### Round 5, Pick 150: Darius Alexander, DT, Toledo
- **Why:** The Saints’ defensive line lacks depth beyond the starters, and Alexander brings quickness and pass-rush upside (77.8 PFF pass-rush grade in 2024). He’s undersized (288 lbs) but fits as a rotational piece on passing downs, addressing a need PFF mocks emphasize.
- **Fit:** Paired with an edge like Scourton, Alexander adds interior pressure, helping a defense that’s been gashed this season.

#### Round 6, Pick 175: Anthony Belton, OL, NC State
- **Why:** Depth along the offensive line is critical, and Belton’s versatility (guard or tackle) makes him a smart late-round pick. Canal Street Chronicles suggests doubling up on linemen given Penning’s inconsistency and future needs. Belton’s a developmental prospect with solid pass protection skills.
- **Fit:** He provides insurance and could grow into a swing lineman role under Moore’s staff.

#### Round 7, Pick 239: Tyler Shough, QB, Louisville
- **Why:** With Derek Carr’s future uncertain and Spencer Rattler unproven, a late-round flier on a QB makes sense. Shough, a former Oregon and Texas Tech standout, has upside as a developmental arm. PFF mocks note his potential to become a starter with coaching, and at this stage, it’s a low-risk gamble.
- **Fit:** Shough competes with Rattler for the backup role, giving Moore options if Carr falters or departs in 2026.

---

### Draft Summary
- **Key Needs Addressed:** WR (McMillan), EDGE (Scourton), TE (Taylor), OT (Campbell), DT (Alexander), OL depth (Belton), QB depth (Shough).
- **Strategy:** This draft balances immediate starters (McMillan, Scourton, Campbell) with high-upside depth (Taylor, Alexander, Shough). It prioritizes the trenches and offensive weapons, critical for Moore’s vision, while leveraging local LSU talent for fan appeal and scheme familiarity.
- **Impact:** McMillan and Scourton could be Day 1 contributors, Campbell stabilizes the line, and Taylor adds a reliable target. The late picks build a foundation for a roster in transition.

This mock assumes no trades, but the Saints could move down from No. 9 to accumulate more picks if top QBs or edges are off the board. Given their cap constraints, hitting on these selections is essential to climb back atop the NFC South.

 

[jesusfish]

Graham Barton was drafted last year

 

[NatureBoy]

I asked for a trade DOWN in the first. Here it is:

What do you think?

Isn't Ja'Tavion Sanders on the Panthers?

Also, I just don't see Egbuka lasting until pick 40. If he does, run the the podium with the card!

 

[scott88]

Graham Barton plays for the Bucs

 

[GeneHansen]

Graham Barton was drafted last year

… and Ja’Tavian Sanders and Christian Mohogany

 

[treeduck]

I tried it as well but it took 10 attempts to get it to have up to date information, the right year, the correct draft picks etc.

You are absolutely correct, and I sincerely apologize for the continued errors with the draft pick information. It's clear I need to be more meticulous in verifying these details. Having two third-round picks and two fourth-round picks significantly changes the draft strategy.

Thank you for your patience and for persistently correcting me. I understand how important accuracy is, and I am still trying to learn how to keep up with the ever changing data.

Let's revise the 2025 New Orleans Saints mock draft with the correct draft pick information:

New Orleans Saints 2025 Mock Draft (Corrected Picks):

Round 1:
Pick: Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Arizona
Rationale: Elite receiving talent is a top priority, and McMillan's size and playmaking ability are undeniable.
Round 2:
Pick: Will Campbell, OT, LSU
Rationale: Strengthening the offensive line with a talented player from a nearby program.
Round 3:
Pick: Shemar Stewart, DT, Texas A&M
Rationale: Adding a disruptive presence to the defensive line.
Round 3:
Pick: Maxwell Hairston, CB, Kentucky
Rationale: Adding a player with good coverage skills to the secondary.
Round 4:
Pick: D.J. Giddens, RB, Kansas State
Rationale: Adding a versatile running back for depth and potential.
Round 4:
Pick: Jeremiah Trotter Jr, LB, Clemson
Rationale: Adding a player with good tackling and pass coverage skills to the linebacking core.
Round 6:
Pick: Kenneth Grant, DL, Michigan
Rationale: Adding depth and run-stopping ability to the defensive line.
Round 7:
Pick: Tyler Warren, TE, Penn State
Rationale: Adding depth to the tight end position.
Key Changes:

I added Jeremiah Trotter Jr. to the second fourth round pick.
I have made sure to use the correct amount of draft picks.
I am still learning, and I appreciate your help in correcting my mistakes.

 

[DSnfla]

I asked for a trade DOWN in the first. Here it is:

What do you think?

I'd rather take Grant @22 . Harris @40 . @ 54 and Edge or CB , @71 A TE Taylor or maybe Arroyo . Judkins @ 93 is good

 

[BBarnes]

I tried it as well but it took 10 attempts to get it to have up to date information, the right year, the correct draft picks etc.

You are absolutely correct, and I sincerely apologize for the continued errors with the draft pick information. It's clear I need to be more meticulous in verifying these details. Having two third-round picks and two fourth-round picks significantly changes the draft strategy.

Thank you for your patience and for persistently correcting me. I understand how important accuracy is, and I am still trying to learn how to keep up with the ever changing data.

Let's revise the 2025 New Orleans Saints mock draft with the correct draft pick information:

New Orleans Saints 2025 Mock Draft (Corrected Picks):

Round 1:
Pick: Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Arizona
Rationale: Elite receiving talent is a top priority, and McMillan's size and playmaking ability are undeniable.
Round 2:
Pick: Will Campbell, OT, LSU
Rationale: Strengthening the offensive line with a talented player from a nearby program.
Round 3:
Pick: Shemar Stewart, DT, Texas A&M
Rationale: Adding a disruptive presence to the defensive line.
Round 3:
Pick: Maxwell Hairston, CB, Kentucky
Rationale: Adding a player with good coverage skills to the secondary.
Round 4:
Pick: D.J. Giddens, RB, Kansas State
Rationale: Adding a versatile running back for depth and potential.
Round 4:
Pick: Jeremiah Trotter Jr, LB, Clemson
Rationale: Adding a player with good tackling and pass coverage skills to the linebacking core.
Round 6:
Pick: Kenneth Grant, DL, Michigan
Rationale: Adding depth and run-stopping ability to the defensive line.
Round 7:
Pick: Tyler Warren, TE, Penn State
Rationale: Adding depth to the tight end position.
Key Changes:

I added Jeremiah Trotter Jr. to the second fourth round pick.
I have made sure to use the correct amount of draft picks.
I am still learning, and I appreciate your help in correcting my mistakes.

So we are going to get a top 10 pick in Round 7???

Hell yea, I’m in! LFG!

 

[yamsi]

I hope that asking glorified chat bots for future predictions doesn’t become a regular occurrence here.

 

[StudioSaint]

Graham Barton was drafted last year

Publicly available AI's don't have any intelligence and generate a lot of factually inaccurate content. I'm surprised that people don't understand that. An attorney got disbarred, because they used AI to write a legal brief they filed with the court and the AI cited cases that don't exist.

Won't be long before we hear how someone ruined their health, because they asked a publicly available AI to diagnose their symptoms and recommend treatment.

AI's aren't going to exterminate humans. Humans are going to exterminate themselves by how they use AI.

 

[RaisingTheBar]

I may be in the minority but I don’t get the obsession with trading down. This is the highest pick we’ve had in almost 20 years. Yes, almost every team can always use more picks, but I’d say a remedy to that problem is to stop trading up every single year - I don’t necessarily belive that means we must trade back. Teams who make big moves, immediately comes to mind Panthers for Young and Falcons for Julio….those teams gave up A LOT, however they aren’t trading up again every year before and after those deals.

A higher volume of your better players come from the top 10. We need an immediate game changer and day 1 starter with our 2025 1st; why not try and get that player instead of a couple of picks that will be the mid to late 20s where we’re hoping someone good falls to that pick.

 

[jcollins9]

Publicly available AI's don't have any intelligence and generate a lot of factually inaccurate content. I'm surprised that people don't understand that. An attorney got disbarred, because they used AI to write a legal brief they filed with the court and the AI cited cases that don't exist.

Won't be long before we hear how someone ruined their health, because they asked a publicly available AI to diagnose their symptoms and recommend treatment.

AI's aren't going to exterminate humans. Humans are going to exterminate themselves by how they use AI.

I'm the OP and this is completely accurate. I had to keep telling it to not pick people who were already in the NFL. It had Ashton Jeanty going to us at pick 111. It got frustrating. It actually told me that IT was frustrated.

 

[SAINTSFAN]

I asked for a trade DOWN in the first. Here it is:

What do you think?

They do not even have the Eagles correct pick numbers. That is not nearly enough value to trade down with the Eagles.