Can we see Carr clearly now? (3 Viewers)

[tak]

Can we see clearly now that Carr may not be the shiny new object but he is the best QB right now?
Rattler is going to be a solid QB but he is not on Carr's level yet. He didn't see a lot of wide open receivers today and had under thrown balls that Carr would've hit all day.
Two things can be true at one time. Rattler has great potential but Carr is a solid QB when given a clean pocket.

 

[SweetT]

Sir, this is a Wendy’s

 

[MV2]

DA is the main problem. His specialty is supposed to be defense and they've been bad for 4 weeks. His constant calling of zone plays in short yardage situations is mind boggling. His blitz packages don't work and he doesn't protect his weaker links like he used to. Out "best" players are old and our "youth" is not winning their battles.

Kubiak started off hot, but his play calling has been meh to me. We came out in the 3rd quarter and stopped moving Rattler around and he began to get pressured. We never adjusted to their blitz and our oline was constantly misaligned. Shading to the right when the pressure was coming from the left. No screens, reverses, or anything to slow them down. Only hot read seems to be AK which is obvious. Yes we miss Ruiz, McCoy, Taysom & Olave, but our WR corp is not good beyond two guys and our O-Line depth is atrocious. Jamaal is bad so we are just running AK into the ground. Need Miller back asap and to trade for a WR.

On another note, Olave and the concussions is concerning. It's every year now and it's not from some crazy hard blows. I thought that hit should have been flagged, but whether it's with different equipment something, it's an issue.

 

[Koolbrees]

Can we see clearly now that Carr may not be the shiny new object but he is the best QB right now?
Rattler is going to be a solid QB but he is not on Carr's level yet. He didn't see a lot of wide open receivers today and had under thrown balls that Carr would've hit.

I’ll take Rattler right now over Carr any day of the week. Carr is NOT it…PERIOD!

 

[Saint603]

After being in the league more than a decade he's about as good as Rattler, yes.

 

[BayouSAINTJoe]

Carr wasn't going to lead us to a W today either

 

[The Unrest Cure]

I love everyone's faith that Rattler will be solid. But I think this team is more than one solid NFL quarterback from being good.

 

[Sailorsaint]

I love everyone's faith that Rattler will be solid. But I think this team is more than one solid NFL quarterback from being good.

No, but it’s a start.

 

[Saint Jack]

Rattler made some rookie mistakes, but I’d still take him over Carr.

 

[meily]

Rattler is talented in his own right this is not a Carr vs anybody, once he's healthy he is back to starting.

 

[ELLIASJWILLIAMS]

DA is the main problem. His specialty is supposed to be defense and they've been bad for 4 weeks. His constant calling of zone plays in short yardage situations is mind boggling. His blitz packages don't work and he doesn't protect his weaker links like he used to. Out "best" players are old and our "youth" is not winning their battles.

Kubiak started off hot, but his play calling has been meh to me. We came out in the 3rd quarter and stopped moving Rattler around and he began to get pressured. We never adjusted to their blitz and our oline was constantly misaligned. Shading to the right when the pressure was coming from the left. No screens, reverses, or anything to slow them down. Only hot read seems to be AK which is obvious. Yes we miss Ruiz, McCoy, Taysom & Olave, but our WR corp is not good beyond two guys and our O-Line depth is atrocious. Jamaal is bad so we are just running AK into the ground. Need Miller back asap and to trade for a WR.

On another note, Olave and the concussions is concerning. It's every year now and it's not from some crazy hard blows. I thought that hit should have been flagged, but whether it's with different equipment something, it's an issue.

Defense is old. Most out out draft capital has gone to offense, meanwhile we let a good amount of defensive take talent walk out the building.

 

[The Unrest Cure]

No, but it’s a start.

I'm too old to embrace starts anymore. 40+ years of Saints fandom has learned to translate that into "excuse for another disappointing year".

 

[Mojomajik9]

Rattler wasn’t perfect today and made some rookie mistakes. That said he is not the reason why the Saints lost today. The defense and DA hold that distinction.

 

[mg6035]

I love everyone's faith that Rattler will be solid. But I think this team is more than one solid NFL quarterback from being good.

Duh. No disrespect meant. This team needs to be blown up and rebuilt. Old, slow and quits at the first sign of trouble. The defense totally quit in the second half.

 

[sleepingbunch]

It could be Carr, Rattler...hell, prime Tom Brady, Mahomes, Montana......with Allen as HC our team's ceiling is 9-8. Allen is the problem.

Can't really compare Carr and Rattler based on the last few games due to the complete dysfunction of the rest of the team.