HC is important for sure but QB is still what matters most (1 Viewer)

[3ParStillDriver]

Matt Cassel says your full of it.

So does Alex Smith, Kirk Cousins and Sam Darnold.

 

[WilliamBrees]

What do you think Carr's ceiling is as a QB? He will be 34 next season and has never sniffed a playoff run.

Out of the last 30 SB winners, only two: Brad Johnson and Matt Stafford are the oldest two QBs to win their first SB. Both were 34. Carr is NOT winning a SB this year unless we trade him to be a backup to KC.

So what's the point of Carr? He's decent enough to get you to a bad record but not bad enough to bottom our for a top pick to get the next QB.

He's pointless and not to mention, I don't like him, ha.

Start Rattler, I don't care. What's the downside? Id say he's 90 percent not the next guy but hey, there's a chance. I 100 percent know Carr ain't that guy.

Take the cap hit. Move on. He's cancer.

Carr bears the Commanders, Raiders, and Bucs.

 

[Elvis]

Mccarthy is known as a great developer of QB's.

Aaron Brooks had his best years with Mccarthy, and was out of the league 2 years after he left.

Is he? He inherited Aaron Rodgers and Dak while they were already elite players. I don't think he's ever developed a rookie QB.

 

[SigFreudianSlip]

I agree but it’s so dang hard to get a marquee QB.

 

[SigFreudianSlip]

What do you think Carr's ceiling is as a QB? He will be 34 next season and has never sniffed a playoff run.

Out of the last 30 SB winners, only two: Brad Johnson and Matt Stafford are the oldest two QBs to win their first SB. Both were 34. Carr is NOT winning a SB this year unless we trade him to be a backup to KC.

So what's the point of Carr? He's decent enough to get you to a bad record but not bad enough to bottom our for a top pick to get the next QB.

He's pointless and not to mention, I don't like him, ha.

Start Rattler, I don't care. What's the downside? Id say he's 90 percent not the next guy but hey, there's a chance. I 100 percent know Carr ain't that guy.

Take the cap hit. Move on. He's cancer.

I’m apathetic towards Carr, don’t mind at all if he drives the tank next season…having said that, I don’t think he will ever win a playoff game.

 

[Pkessling]

Carr bears the Commanders, Raiders, and Bucs.

?

 

[Elvis]

QB is the most import position on the field and you'll get no argument from me on that. But the QBs we have aren't attractive to every (any?) coach, we have no ability to sign a new one and there are none in this draft that are difference makers. Someone has to be hired and someone is going to have to coach this roster because a new QB isn't in the cards for 2025.

 

[Centmssaint1]

A great play caller/OC/DC doesn’t translate to a great HC.

 

[SuperSaint]

Is he? He inherited Aaron Rodgers and Dak while they were already elite players. I don't think he's ever developed a rookie QB.

I'm not sure it matters, the Saints are in denial about how far away they are from competing for a championship, you look at the dominance of the Eagles D-line today, we're years away from that.