Offline
I know. Different eras, just want to hear your takes on who you’d rather have if building a team, between Irvin and Smith.
Who is the better receiver in your opinion? Another thread has me thinking about this. I am firmly in the camp of Smith being better. And the Ring argument holds no water for me as it’s a team game. Irvin was on a Dynasty type team. Imo. Drew should have 3 or 4 rings if we could field a competent defense every year, and no one is diminishing his first ballot HOF status. So, who’s better? Smith vs. Irvin?
Stats are heavily in Smith’s favor but I do understand he played after Irvin in a different era. I get that. I’d still take him over Irvin.
Who is the better receiver in your opinion? Another thread has me thinking about this. I am firmly in the camp of Smith being better. And the Ring argument holds no water for me as it’s a team game. Irvin was on a Dynasty type team. Imo. Drew should have 3 or 4 rings if we could field a competent defense every year, and no one is diminishing his first ballot HOF status. So, who’s better? Smith vs. Irvin?
Stats are heavily in Smith’s favor but I do understand he played after Irvin in a different era. I get that. I’d still take him over Irvin.