Opinion Ranking the offseason NFL coaching hires (1 Viewer)

Joined
Nov 20, 2018
Messages
1,567
Reaction score
3,876
Age
43
Location
Covington, LA
Offline
I'll give give some thoughts on each hire.

1. Chicago Bears- Congratulations... on paper you are a desirable place to coach. With 1 winning season over the past 12 years, surely this will definitely turn the tide. You have the newbie QB who was not good and showed very little promise but thank goodness he's still within the can't be a bust window cause we are going to use the coaching card. Bears seemed to have a diligent coaching search but ultimately went after the lazy but obvious coach who did a great job of establishing perceived credibility over the past 2+ years. Ben Johnson may do well. Time will tell.

2. New Orleans Saints- Of course assuming we hire Kellen Moore. With Philly's playoff rise and ultimate Super Bowl birth, its very difficult to not give Mickey credit with this hire. You know... despite all of the real and some perceived obstacles with our organization. Sure, we don't have an envious cap situation at all. Derek Carr has not proven to be a bust with new orleans. He has played very good ball at times but also has not carried our team single handedly like an upper echelon qb might be able to do. Kellen Moore seems to be a promising offensive mind which is critical in this league. This will be a great hire for the organization despite the recent negative drama thrown our way.

3. New England Patriots- I'm begrudgingly am putting them this high. I sort of don't want to. BUT Mike Vrabel is a proven good culture guy. Has tons of skins on the wall and comes from the cloth of the organization. He struggled to fix the qb position, derek henry carried the titans for years. I seem to see a lack of innovation with his coaching. I want to knock the Patriots down bigly for such a terrible hire less than a year prior and firing what's his face. Where is the nfl criticism dragging kraft through the mud on that hire. This was a safe hire. Fell in Kraft's lap.

4. New York Jets- Congrats. What a catch. You got Aaron Glenn. Man, you stole him from new orleans. Ya'll are so wonderful. That Aaron Rodgers trade is looking so great for you guys. Devante Adams did nothing to help ya'll. Where's all the organizational shame thrown the jets way? They have done nothing but fail repeatingly and seemingly are trying to strike the same type of cord previously tried with an Aaron Glenn hire. Look, i think AG is a great person. Can be a great leader. But what is really his gameplan to make this team better on the field catering to Arod's low key drama. Glenn's season ended in a flaming pile of trash. I get it, you had lots of injuries. You get no sympathy from a saints fan. Glenn is getting a lot of points really just coming from the Detroit tree that dan campbell did a heck of a job assembling a staff and they struck gold repeatedly in the draft.

5a. 5b TIED. Jacksonville Jags and Las Vegas Raiders. I won't spend a ton of time on these hires. Jags seemed to go the desperate route. Owner is willing to make bold moves constantly. few of which pan out. He probably overpaid for Coen not that it matters. Coen has a lot to prove, does he have enough skin on the wall to command an organization yet? He did well with the bucs but baker has just been playing good ball and the bucs actually have had good weapons on the field. Raiders seemed to be a very boring hire. Very bad that big tom brady and the daring vegas city couldn't haul in a bigger fish of a coach. Pete is a safe hire, he'll assemble a good staff and have them playing better ball but it won't be a transcending hire. Very tough division.

6. Dallas Cowboys- Sorry, your entire head coach search was awful. You didn't even have the courage to fire Mike Mccarthy. Ya'll parted ways weeks later. You had a conversation with Deion Sanders. lmao. like what the heck. Your search was lazy, non aggressive and unseemingly rushed for zero reason. You are america's team (were) have some good talent and couldn't get any hot candidate to come sniff around. You just let Dan Quinn leave the building a year ago and he showed up in the nfc championship game with a rookie qb a year later. Horrible optics all around. But hey, lets keep banging on Mrs. Benson cause she's a woman.
 
Plus, they never did catch that anthrax guy
1738185298708.png
 
Placing us 2nd is crazy.

Kellen Moore is a fine offensive guy but he's not this incredible offensive guy mind like McVay.

Herbert had arguably his worst season under Kellen and he was let go within one year. Cowboys FO/Fans also had major issues with his situational play calling. (going away from what is working, throwing the ball when you're up, etc)

He's on an Eagles team with the most talented offensive roster in the entire league. Dude has pro bowlers/all pros at QB, OL, RB, and WR.

I'm not "down" on Moore by any means in fact i'm quite excited. He's just going from the most talented offense in the league to arguably one of the least talented.

Oh and he's never been a head coach before. Ever.
 
I'll give give some thoughts on each hire.

1. Chicago Bears- Congratulations... on paper you are a desirable place to coach. With 1 winning season over the past 12 years, surely this will definitely turn the tide. You have the newbie QB who was not good and showed very little promise but thank goodness he's still within the can't be a bust window cause we are going to use the coaching card. Bears seemed to have a diligent coaching search but ultimately went after the lazy but obvious coach who did a great job of establishing perceived credibility over the past 2+ years. Ben Johnson may do well. Time will tell.

2. New Orleans Saints- Of course assuming we hire Kellen Moore. With Philly's playoff rise and ultimate Super Bowl birth, its very difficult to not give Mickey credit with this hire. You know... despite all of the real and some perceived obstacles with our organization. Sure, we don't have an envious cap situation at all. Derek Carr has not proven to be a bust with new orleans. He has played very good ball at times but also has not carried our team single handedly like an upper echelon qb might be able to do. Kellen Moore seems to be a promising offensive mind which is critical in this league. This will be a great hire for the organization despite the recent negative drama thrown our way.

3. New England Patriots- I'm begrudgingly am putting them this high. I sort of don't want to. BUT Mike Vrabel is a proven good culture guy. Has tons of skins on the wall and comes from the cloth of the organization. He struggled to fix the qb position, derek henry carried the titans for years. I seem to see a lack of innovation with his coaching. I want to knock the Patriots down bigly for such a terrible hire less than a year prior and firing what's his face. Where is the nfl criticism dragging kraft through the mud on that hire. This was a safe hire. Fell in Kraft's lap.

4. New York Jets- Congrats. What a catch. You got Aaron Glenn. Man, you stole him from new orleans. Ya'll are so wonderful. That Aaron Rodgers trade is looking so great for you guys. Devante Adams did nothing to help ya'll. Where's all the organizational shame thrown the jets way? They have done nothing but fail repeatingly and seemingly are trying to strike the same type of cord previously tried with an Aaron Glenn hire. Look, i think AG is a great person. Can be a great leader. But what is really his gameplan to make this team better on the field catering to Arod's low key drama. Glenn's season ended in a flaming pile of trash. I get it, you had lots of injuries. You get no sympathy from a saints fan. Glenn is getting a lot of points really just coming from the Detroit tree that dan campbell did a heck of a job assembling a staff and they struck gold repeatedly in the draft.

5a. 5b TIED. Jacksonville Jags and Las Vegas Raiders. I won't spend a ton of time on these hires. Jags seemed to go the desperate route. Owner is willing to make bold moves constantly. few of which pan out. He probably overpaid for Coen not that it matters. Coen has a lot to prove, does he have enough skin on the wall to command an organization yet? He did well with the bucs but baker has just been playing good ball and the bucs actually have had good weapons on the field. Raiders seemed to be a very boring hire. Very bad that big tom brady and the daring vegas city couldn't haul in a bigger fish of a coach. Pete is a safe hire, he'll assemble a good staff and have them playing better ball but it won't be a transcending hire. Very tough division.

6. Dallas Cowboys- Sorry, your entire head coach search was awful. You didn't even have the courage to fire Mike Mccarthy. Ya'll parted ways weeks later. You had a conversation with Deion Sanders. lmao. like what the heck. Your search was lazy, non aggressive and unseemingly rushed for zero reason. You are america's team (were) have some good talent and couldn't get any hot candidate to come sniff around. You just let Dan Quinn leave the building a year ago and he showed up in the nfc championship game with a rookie qb a year later. Horrible optics all around. But hey, let’s keep banging on Mrs. Benson cause she's a woman


The Saints should be second to last. Dallas being last. 1) NE 2)Chic 3)Oak 4) Jets 5) Jax 6) Saints (I’m not sure I’d have chose him over KK as OC much less HC 7) Dallas
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Users who are viewing this thread

    Back
    Top Bottom