Reggie or Peterson (1 Viewer)

[Rich Jr]

Better RB

Peterson>>>>>>>Bush

Better fit for this offense

Bush>>>>>>>>>Peterson

Give me Bush please

 

[2fya]

Bush hasnt had a long scoring run yet, and peterson already has 5-6 of them. he brings power ( in which reggie doesnt have any) and also speed. i know that he has a solid offensive line, but they do not have any other offensive weapons to worry about. the defense is always keying in on peterson, and for bush, he also has brees and colston that defenses have to worry about, yet he still hasnt produced a long scoring run

 

[redlandssaintsson]

Bush, You can't really line Peterson up on the outside, as a reciever. Thats where I think Reggie surpasses Peterson. If you line up Peterson and some other RB in the back field, we know its a run play or a pass to a reciever. If you line up Reggie and some RB in the back field, it could be a run, it could be a reciever pass, it could be reggie deep in the endzone. I can't imagine a better fit for the offense.

 

[BoNcHiE]

Bush hasnt had a long scoring run yet, and peterson already has 5-6 of them. he brings power ( in which reggie doesnt have any) and also speed. i know that he has a solid offensive line, but they do not have any other offensive weapons to worry about. the defense is always keying in on peterson, and for bush, he also has brees and colston that defenses have to worry about, yet he still hasnt produced a long scoring run

The whole "Reggie has no power" stuff is utter bullcrap.

 

[State Of Affairs]

Bush hasnt had a long scoring run yet, and peterson already has 5-6 of them. he brings power ( in which reggie doesnt have any) and also speed. i know that he has a solid offensive line, but they do not have any other offensive weapons to worry about. the defense is always keying in on peterson, and for bush, he also has brees and colston that defenses have to worry about, yet he still hasnt produced a long scoring run

Dude, without Bush, our offense is nothing. Do you know those little 1st downs that Bush gets when he turns a little swing pass into an 8 yard gain, you know the ones that he makes look easy, so easy that many fans don't appreciate that MOST backs in the NFL arent agile enough, have good enough hand, acceleration and explosiveness to make that play.

AP may be the best running back ever and 10X's the back Reggie is but Reggie is a pure BALLER and I really don't think he's very appreciated.

Lastly, I seem to recall several long TD plays by Reggie last year in his rookie year. I believe Reggie was a MAJOR factor in the Saints going to the NFCCG. Something they've never done before and it sounds to me like you don't have much respect for him??? Anyway.......

 

[Death Incarnate]

Dude, without Bush, our offense is nothing. Do you know those little 1st downs that Bush gets when he turns a little swing pass into an 8 yard gain, you know the ones that he makes look easy, so easy that many fans don't appreciate that MOST backs in the NFL arent agile enough, have good enough hand, acceleration and explosiveness to make that play.

AP may be the best running back ever and 10X's the back Reggie is but Reggie is a pure BALLER and I really don't think he's very appreciated.

Lastly, I seem to recall several long TD plays by Reggie last year in his rookie year. I believe Reggie was a MAJOR factor in the Saints going to the NFCCG. Something they've never done before and it sounds to me like you don't have much respect for him??? Anyway.......

lus-un2: i totally agree

 

[Brock Meaux]

Troy Davis? I suppose you meant Terrell Davis?

And Tim Biakabatuka? Why is he listed? That's like comparing a Porsche, Lamborghini, & Ferrari with a Ford Escort.

I'm pretty sure my post was fairly clear. At least I hope so.

 

[texasjefe]

the defense is always keying in on peterson,

A million Chargers' fans disagree.

Aren't there some fantasy boards you can take Reggie vs. Purple Jesus to?

 

[llama]

I hope we draft Cap'n Crunch next year.

 

[Jay Foster]

Everyone,

When you come up with some idea that you think is fantastic and how we should trade Brees or Reggie or Deuce or Colston or whoever so that we can get every great defensive back in the league, along with a few offensive linemen, a top notch kicker, a great middle linebacker, etc., I would suggest stepping away from the computer before posting it.