Time to start Book (1 Viewer)

[UFCSaint]

Worst case scenario is that we get a top 10 draft pick. Best case scenario is that we discover we have a QB on our roster who will be cheap for 3 more years.

It's obvious that neither Hill nor Siemian are the answer. And the jury is still out on Winston.

 

[WhoDat?DrewDat]

Throwing a rookie QB behind this OLine without any receivers is asking to get him killed.

Also how is the jury out on Winston?? Did you not see how much better he was than Hill and Trevor?

 

[26ISTHEMAN]

Agree 100%.

 

[HouseCall]

Worst case scenario is that we get a top 10 draft pick. Best case scenario is that we discover we have a QB on our roster who will be cheap for 3 more years.

It's obvious that neither Hill nor Siemian are the answer. And the jury is still out on Winston.

But you really don’t learn anything about Book by throwing him to the wolves because there aren’t NFL receivers on our team.

He’d be eaten alive and broken.

 

[UFCSaint]

Throwing a rookie QB behind this OLine without any receivers is asking to get him killed.

Armstead and Ram may be back next week. Along with Kamara...agausnt the Jets. Good way to build some confidence in a rookie

 

[Saints 318]

its time what else we got left

 

[Taker597]

No. If Book is your 4th string. It's probably a pretty obvious reason. He was terrible in Preseason.

 

[Infoman]

It’s time for another drank too ladies. Cheers!

 

[UFCSaint]

No. If Book is your 4th string. It's probably a pretty obvious reason. He was terrible in Preseason.

Well then by all means let's stay with Hill and Siemian

 

[Taker597]

Well then by all means let's stay with Hill and Siemian

By all means... Play musical chair. It won't change a thing. Season is over.

 

[SaintsBrah]

Worst case scenario is that we get a top 10 draft pick. Best case scenario is that we discover we have a QB on our roster who will be cheap for 3 more years.

It's obvious that neither Hill nor Siemian are the answer. And the jury is still out on Winston.

Book is apparently so bad Payton wouldn’t even let him be active. If you know better than Sean maybe I’m wrong then

 

[JackDiesel]

Nah continue to let Hill and Siemen be bullet sponges. Don't kill the rookies confidence by putting him in the middle of that cluster.

 

[Mississippi Saints Fan]

If you thought Siemain and Taysom have been bad, I can only imagine a young rookie, playing behind this backup line with limited weapons. Sheesh, I don’t think he’d have a chance to show us anything. Are you thinking he might pull off the impossible? Is that a fair way to gauge what you “might” have in him?

 

[UFCSaint]

By all means... Play musical chair. It won't change a thing. Season is over.

Agree. So it's time to see what we have. We have no salary cap to make a big QB signing in the off-season. Should we wait until next season to see what Book has?

 

[SubmarineMike]

Look, when you are arguing about who is best at QB2, you are always going to be looking at a tough season.

Right now, I believe TH7 gives us our best chance to win. Especially with this beat up O-line.

I am not sure I believe that Seimien is as bad as this O-line made him look, but I am fairly confident that the O-line would make Book look awful.

This isn't a "Taysom against the world" post - it is a "Taysom against our situation" post. There is just not a better option right now.