Weeelllll, let’s be a little fair. Look at the date on the first one…we ALL know what’s happening there. That’s not about corporate greed…that’s about somebody calling in on Christmas week and screwing over colleagues who have to cover the work of the person calling in.then there
are these
that might be part of it, but it's more about a middle management nimrod being a puppet but adopting an illfitting persona
It’s “You’re sick”then there
are these
The myth of the rugged individual is pure bull. I know I’ve said it before but the greatest trick the rich in the USA have ever pulled off is convincing the poor it’s their own fault they’re poor.Interesting read
============
One day, I received an email from a stranger about how the poor are responsible for their own poverty.
It wasn’t the first: I get these missives frequently. These commenters like to claim that those who are economically on the edge just need to “pull themselves up by their bootstraps”, and that people who are struggling probably deserve to do so.
Why? Because these Americans took on educational debt, had children – or even got divorced. And so angry readers call other people out when they accrue such debt but also admonish them when they have not had adequate job retraining to be employable, not seeing the paradox.
These audience members may also blame women for not marrying. And families for living in a city where the cost of living is high, ignoring that that’s where many of the jobs are. They also like to critique individuals for actually wanting to do what they love for a living.
Sadly, these blame-mongers aren’t alone: studies have found that many Republicans think successis something one achieves alone through hard work. And if we don’t manage to do so, it’s our own damn fault.
I’m familiar with this stream of invective because I’ve spent much of the last nine years reporting about the falling middle class and working poor and running a poverty non-profit to boot.
But here was something about that specific comment – in which the writer claimed that we were “all products of our choices” and had to live with the consequences – that made me decide I wanted to get to the bottom of this refrain.
How did this narrative and its flip side – the shame and blame of those who are not victors – become writ?
In order to better understand this mindset, I read books and political speeches going back to the 19th century, all with a similar through-line: Americans should thrive and rise on pluck and hard work alone.
From Walden to The Fountainhead, from the political speeches of Herbert Hoover through Trump, I found an ideological script for the vitriol the letter writers expressed. I also discovered a rich vein of hypocrisy – the Horatio Alger story was actually one of teenagers meeting wealthy benefactors and Alger himself had been run out of his ministry for pedophilic acts.
The cringey Ayn Rand novels that shout we must all survive on our own may be worshipped by wealthy technologists, but Rand herself became dependent in later life, relying on social security and Medicare.
The writings of these compromised figures nevertheless are at the foundation of the thinking of those taking outsized pride in their supposedly self-reliant lives: even though they had had a teen mom, they now earned six figures, one wrote; in the words of another, how they managed to save money yet “had a car, a TV and food” while others like them had not.
Taken together, these responses seemed to be a kind of nationwide bullying of the poor.
I then reported around the US to document the lived experience of ordinary people who had suffered because of our culture’s relentless obsession with bootstrapping. These were different sides of the self-made-man storyline.
There were those who were oppressed by the cult of self-reliance, both monetarily and emotionally. There were also those who benefited from it thanks to inherited wealth or other kinds of inborn privilege who had, in contrast, been thought to be all too deserving their whole lives……
A national bullying of the poor: the trouble with America’s bootstrapping myth
Centuries of American thought support a hypocritical ideology that can be difficult to escape even when we want towww.theguardian.com
To where? Do you know yet?
I wish MBR would agree to this but I fear I will have to work until I drop.
Possibly Domenica in the Caribbean. Buy a house there and you qualify for citizenship. Beautiful tropical island with friendly people, and still largely undiscovered due to the absence or a deep-water harbor.
Are you talking about in general or on this site? If the latter, you’re overstating it. If the former…well, you’re not wrong in a lot of places
But in places where you wouldn’t…well, accusations of racism and transphobia abound similarly. People tend to suck everywhere 
in general. not this site. on this site or PDB, its only a few specific ones...Are you talking about in general or on this site? If the latter, you’re overstating it. If the former…well, you’re not wrong in a lot of places
I'm never on the PDB, so I can't say myself!
Create an account or login to comment
You must be a member in order to leave a comment
Create account
Create an account on our community. It's easy!
Log in
Already have an account? Log in here.
