Brees Snubbed, but Jordan, Evans, and Sproles included on 2010s All-Decade Roster (1 Viewer)

sainthood

Veteran Starter
Joined
Apr 25, 2004
Messages
858
Reaction score
1,592
Offline
The question is how you rank Aaron Rodgers over Brees for the seasons of 2010 to 2019.

Aaron Rodgers Stats 2010 to 2019 (only played 7 games in 2017 and 9 games in 2013)

PassingRushingFumbles
GGSCompAttPctYdsAvgTDIntSckSckYRateAttYdsAvgTDFUMLost
Total 142.0 142.0 3,187.0 4,925.0 648.8 38,145.0 77.8 305.0 63.0 355.0 2,361.0 1,035.9 489.0 2,552.0 52.0 19.0 54.0 23.0
Average 14.2 14.2 318.7 492.5 64.9 3,814.5 7.8 30.5 6.3 35.5 236.1 103.6 48.9 255.2 5.2 1.9 5.4 2.3

Drew Brees Stats 2010 to 2019 (Brees only played 11 games in 2019)

SeasonTeamPassingRushingFumbles
GGSCompAttPctYdsAvgTDIntSckSckYRateAttYdsAvgTDFUMLost
Total 153.0 153.0 4,170.0 5,997.0 699.1 46,770.0 78.1 345.0 127.0 248.0 1,737.0 1,038.1 236.0 272.0 10.4 16.0 48.0 16.0
Average 15.3 15.3 417.0 599.7 69.9 4,677.0 7.8 34.5 12.7 24.8 173.7 103.8 23.6 27.2 1.0 1.6 5.3 1.8

In every stat other than rushing yards and interceptions Brees out performs Rodgers.

If you look at team success Rodgers has the edge especially given Green Bay's worse years 2013 and 2017 Rodgers was hurt. Brees has four 7 and 9 seasons with no playoffs while Green Bay only has two non playoff seasons plus Rodgers Superbowl season.
I can see based on this why the voters went with Rodgers. However in that time the NFC South has been until recently a much tougher division with the Panthers and the Falcons both going to the Superbowl during this time. No team from the North other than the Packers has sniffed the Superbowl. Although as we know the Vikings have had our number in the playoffs twice.
Total
102​
56​
2​
100​
60​
Average
10.2​
5.6​
1​
64%​
1.60
10​
6​
63%​
1.9​
Green BayNew Orleans
Wins LossesTieWin %Division RankPlayoffsWins LossesWin %Division RankPlayoffs
2019​
13​
3​
81%​
1​
Lost Conference Championship
13​
3​
81%​
1​
Lost Wild Card Playoffs
2018​
6​
9​
1​
38%​
3​
None
13​
3​
81%​
1​
Lost Conference Championship
2017​
7​
9​
44%​
3​
None
11​
5​
69%​
1​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
2016​
10​
6​
63%​
1​
Lost Conference Championship
7​
9​
44%​
3​
None
2015​
10​
6​
63%​
2​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
7​
9​
44%​
3​
None
2014​
12​
4​
75%​
1​
Lost Conference Championship
7​
9​
44%​
2​
None
2013​
8​
7​
1​
50%​
1​
Lost Wild Card Playoffs
11​
5​
69%​
2​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
2012​
11​
5​
69%​
1​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
7​
9​
44%​
3​
None
2011​
15​
1​
94%​
1​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
13​
3​
81%​
1​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
2010​
10​
6​
63%​
2​
Won Superbowl
11​
5​
69%​
2​
Lost Wild Card Playoffs
 

LUX

Ride til I die!
VIP Contributor
Joined
Feb 22, 2013
Messages
2,925
Reaction score
4,879
Location
Louisiana
Offline
The question is how you rank Aaron Rodgers over Brees for the seasons of 2010 to 2019.

Aaron Rodgers Stats 2010 to 2019 (only played 7 games in 2017 and 9 games in 2013)

PassingRushingFumbles
GGSCompAttPctYdsAvgTDIntSckSckYRateAttYdsAvgTDFUMLost
Total 142.0 142.0 3,187.0 4,925.0 648.8 38,145.0 77.8 305.0 63.0 355.0 2,361.0 1,035.9 489.0 2,552.0 52.0 19.0 54.0 23.0
Average 14.2 14.2 318.7 492.5 64.9 3,814.5 7.8 30.5 6.3 35.5 236.1 103.6 48.9 255.2 5.2 1.9 5.4 2.3
Drew Brees Stats 2010 to 2019 (Brees only played 11 games in 2019)


SeasonTeamPassingRushingFumbles
GGSCompAttPctYdsAvgTDIntSckSckYRateAttYdsAvgTDFUMLost
Total 153.0 153.0 4,170.0 5,997.0 699.1 46,770.0 78.1 345.0 127.0 248.0 1,737.0 1,038.1 236.0 272.0 10.4 16.0 48.0 16.0
Average 15.3 15.3 417.0 599.7 69.9 4,677.0 7.8 34.5 12.7 24.8 173.7 103.8 23.6 27.2 1.0 1.6 5.3 1.8
In every stat other than rushing yards and interceptions Brees out performs Rodgers.


If you look at team success Rodgers has the edge especially given Green Bay's worse years 2013 and 2017 Rodgers was hurt. Brees has four 7 and 9 seasons with no playoffs while Green Bay only has two non playoff seasons plus Rodgers Superbowl season.
I can see based on this why the voters went with Rodgers. However in that time the NFC South has been until recently a much tougher division with the Panthers and the Falcons both going to the Superbowl during this time. No team from the North other than the Packers has sniffed the Superbowl. Although as we know the Vikings have had our number in the playoffs twice.
Total
102​
56​
2​
100​
60​
Average
10.2​
5.6​
1​
64%​
1.60
10​
6​
63%​
1.9​
Green BayNew Orleans
WinsLossesTieWin %Division RankPlayoffsWinsLossesWin %Division RankPlayoffs
2019​
13​
3​
81%​
1​
Lost Conference Championship
13​
3​
81%​
1​
Lost Wild Card Playoffs
2018​
6​
9​
1​
38%​
3​
None
13​
3​
81%​
1​
Lost Conference Championship
2017​
7​
9​
44%​
3​
None
11​
5​
69%​
1​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
2016​
10​
6​
63%​
1​
Lost Conference Championship
7​
9​
44%​
3​
None
2015​
10​
6​
63%​
2​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
7​
9​
44%​
3​
None
2014​
12​
4​
75%​
1​
Lost Conference Championship
7​
9​
44%​
2​
None
2013​
8​
7​
1​
50%​
1​
Lost Wild Card Playoffs
11​
5​
69%​
2​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
2012​
11​
5​
69%​
1​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
7​
9​
44%​
3​
None
2011​
15​
1​
94%​
1​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
13​
3​
81%​
1​
Lost Divisional Playoffs
2010​
10​
6​
63%​
2​
Won Superbowl
11​
5​
69%​
2​
Lost Wild Card Playoffs

Some of your number look strange. Maybe its the formatting, but some categories and numbers don't make sense.

Anyway, they are probably choosing QBs by MVP and Super Bowl wins. I'm not going to click on the link, but it's probably why Brees is not there.
 

SigFreudianSlip

Subscribing Member
VIP Subscribing Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2002
Messages
30,074
Reaction score
37,004
Age
45
Location
Tennessee
Offline
Whats the deal with Brees being screwed over all the time ??? Seriously.....I honestly dont get it.
It really is sad how much disrespect he gets. All he does is smash records and breaks his own records numerous times.

Let down by the D not enough titles.
Also I believe he’s viewed outside of New Orleans as having benefited from the pass happy new league. Viewed as a record chaser.
 

COACHTDL

Squad Leader
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
590
Reaction score
781
Location
LAFAYETTE
Offline
Moronic.. I am so tired of the F...ing hate Drew gets. Look at the stats for the decade. Drew dominates all. No Superbowl is what they say.
This list is not a team thing, it is about the players. Rodgers over Brees? What? Not even close. Don't understand the Rodgers love at all.
 

SweetT

Old alias known as FLASH
VIP Contributor
Joined
Aug 28, 2008
Messages
20,901
Reaction score
38,595
Age
43
Location
beyond thunderdome
Online
Let down by the D not enough titles.
Also I believe he’s viewed outside of New Orleans as having benefited from the pass happy new league. Viewed as a record chaser.
That’s a fair point, but voters just can’t dismiss the stats/records if they will throw Aaron Rodgers in there. Same amount of titles, almost the same amount of victories in that decade, and Drew just dominates him in the stats category. I mean, this should have been an easy decision by the voters. There is literally no justifiable argument for voting Rodgers over Brees here. I came to terms with Drew never getting a league MVP long time ago. The same for him never being considered the GOAT QB, but to just dismiss him for the all decade team is just about as blatant as blatant gets.
 

SigFreudianSlip

Subscribing Member
VIP Subscribing Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2002
Messages
30,074
Reaction score
37,004
Age
45
Location
Tennessee
Offline
That’s a fair point, but voters just can’t dismiss the stats/records if they will throw Aaron Rodgers in there. Same amount of titles, almost the same amount of victories in that decade, and Drew just dominates him in the stats category. I mean, this should have been an easy decision by the voters. There is literally no justifiable argument for voting Rodgers over Brees here. I came to terms with Drew never getting a league MVP long time ago. The same for him never being considered the GOAT QB, but to just dismiss him for the all decade team is just about as blatant as blatant gets.

I ? agree. Aaron was more flamboyant, fun slinging and exciting, to many imo.
There is no question who the better QB is to you and me. But not so easy outside of the 504.
 

SigFreudianSlip

Subscribing Member
VIP Subscribing Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2002
Messages
30,074
Reaction score
37,004
Age
45
Location
Tennessee
Offline
 

Sumdude34

All-Pro
Joined
Feb 17, 2009
Messages
1,803
Reaction score
3,109
Age
28
Location
Mid City
Offline
Lol feels like a bad schrodinger's cat joke at this point.

Media - "Drew Brees is not a top 10 QB of all time"

Us - "Why not, he holds all the records?

Media - "Well, he's never won any major awards"

Us - "Well that's because you don't vote for him. Why don't you vote for him."

Media - "Because he's not a top 10 QB of all time!"

And round and round it goes. I'm over it. I don't care anymore. They will never be able to write him out of the reccord books.
 

SigFreudianSlip

Subscribing Member
VIP Subscribing Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2002
Messages
30,074
Reaction score
37,004
Age
45
Location
Tennessee
Offline
Lol feels like a bad schrodinger's cat joke at this point.

Media - "Drew Brees is not a top 10 QB of all time"

Us - "Why not, he holds all the records?

Media - "Well, he's never won any major awards"

Us - "Well that's because you don't vote for him. Why don't you vote for him."

Media - "Because he's not a top 10 QB of all time!"

And round and round it goes. I'm over it. I don't care anymore. They will never be able to write him out of the reccord books.

Great way to look at it.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom