Dr. Pepper or Mr. Pibb (1 Viewer)

Which soda is better?

  • Dr. Pepper

    Votes: 33 63.5%
  • Mr. Pibb

    Votes: 8 15.4%
  • They taste the same

    Votes: 11 21.2%

  • Total voters
    52
Missing the "both are gross" option.
 
Dr. Pepper

Mister Pibb didn’t even bother to get his degree.

mEcBcN.gif
 
Flaming Dr. Pepper


I've had many of those at the Gold Mine and they really do taste like Dr. Pepper. Than again after about 8 of them, everything tastes like Dr. Pepper.
 
Mr Pibb and Dr Pepper are like Coke and Pepsi.
They do not really taste the same, but both taste similar enough...
Coke & Pepsi are nowhere near similar enough, Pepsi makes me vomit. I can taste the difference between Pibb & Pepper, and both are good but in a different way. HOWEVER, Dr P has come out with a Dr Pepper Cream Soda that is TO DIE FOR!!!
 
Coke & Pepsi are nowhere near similar enough, Pepsi makes me vomit. I can taste the difference between Pibb & Pepper, and both are good but in a different way. HOWEVER, Dr P has come out with a Dr Pepper Cream Soda that is TO DIE FOR!!!
honestly, if I had to choose from coke or pepsi. I do like Pepsi better. Pepsi used to make a real sugar version during the summer, not sure if they still do it, the real sugar made it even better.
But when I drink soda, it's usually Coke zero. it tastes better than the Pepsi version.
 
honestly, if I had to choose from coke or pepsi. I do like Pepsi better. Pepsi used to make a real sugar version during the summer, not sure if they still do it, the real sugar made it even better.
But when I drink soda, it's usually Coke zero. it tastes better than the Pepsi version.
Mountain Dew is a Pepsi product that I really like and is my choice whenever it is available. A few years ago they came out with the "real" sugar version that I don't like since you can actually feel that is isn't fully dissolved into the mix. It is grainy.
 
Mountain Dew is a Pepsi product that I really like and is my choice whenever it is available. A few years ago they came out with the "real" sugar version that I don't like since you can actually feel that is isn't fully dissolved into the mix. It is grainy.



I dont “party” much anymore now that I’m in my 40s.. but back in the times when i was more of a partier, Mountain Dew was my go-to drink of choice becuase it has by far the highest caffeine content of any major soft drink on the market.. if memory serves, Dr Pepper is #2.. of course there was also the great ‘Jolt Cola’ (“All the sugar, Twice the caffeine”) - which I believe can still be found in some niche markets... Anyhow, if i were going to be ‘partying’ back then, I’d have a Big Gulp sized Mountain Dew and then i could party til the wee hours.. the first place i ever had a Mountain Dew in life was at the Popeyes corner of Veterans & David Dr in Ke-Metry , circa the late 1970s when i was about 5.. I can still remember how sweet and delicious this new concoction tasted with the spicy chicken....... These days i have a Mountain Dew about twice a year or so, for me it’s probably like most people are about doing recreational drugs lol
 
My boss and I were discussing these sodas the other day. I am not much of a soda drinker but last week we were in St. Louis and he was going into the gas station and asked if I wanted anything. He. came back with a Dr. Pepper. I pointed out his error and he told me, "does it matter, they both taste the same."

I don't believe they do. Thoughts?
I can taste the difference. I love Mr Pibb whenever I drink a soda. I don’t drink soda often though. Been a while since I had one, I might buy a 6 pack of them.
 
I rarely drink soda any more, but I always preferred Dr Pepper over Mr. Pibb. Much like Sprite and 7Up, Pibb is a little sweeter than Dr Pepper, though not as much as Sprite is over 7Up. I'll drink 7Up, but I don't like Sprite at all, way too sweet. Mr. Pibb isn't overkill like that, but I do like the slightly less sweet Dr Pepper better.

Nowadays, though, on the rare occasion I do have a soda, I opt for Barq's.
Well said all the way around, Drew. I do drink “cokes” — Barq’s RB and Dr. Pepper. (Dr. Pepper has a little more of that “Barq’s bite” than Mr. Pibb)
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Users who are viewing this thread

    Back
    Top Bottom