Honestly, I'd love all three. Jim is great - period. Archie brings the intellectual insight of a former QB into the booth. Hokie conversly brings the emotion. Over the years I have enjoyed listening to all three.
The three of them together would be great. I voted for Jim and Hokie. I like a little color in my color guy. Archie is smart and insightful but a little too dry at times. Hokie's insight is somewhat lacking, but he makes up for it with his palpable excitement.