Making the case to heavily pursue Joe Brady for Head Coach (13 Viewers)

Joined
Oct 24, 2024
Messages
264
Reaction score
482
Location
Kansas City
Offline
Over the past couple of weeks I've grown on the simple idea that Joe Brady is a better candidate than Ben Johnson.

First and foremost, Brady seems to be a QB whisperer. This is obvious from as early as his days at LSU with Burrow at QB as the passing game coordinator. The following article highlights that his ideas helped propel the offense and helped Joe Burrow go from 16 TD's the previous season to 60.


From there he went to Carolina in 2020. It's no secret that the Panthers sucked under Matt Rhule. Joe Brady was fired later Dec 5th in the 2021 season. The Panthers never really took off offensively. But were they that bad? Is it possible that Joe Brady was a scapegoat? Yes. And that the same time No. Teddy Bridgewater had arguably his best season ever under Joe Brady throwing for 3700+ yards. Mike Davis had over 1000 yards from scrimmage. So what was the problem? Scoring. Teddy Bridgewater, after being traded informed on a podcast with Patrick Peterson that Joe Brady never practiced Red Zone, nor 2 minute drills in practice.

It showed. The Panthers were in the bottom half of scoring, despite having an offense that could drive the middle, and back half of the field with no problems.


But why? LSU's offense was quite good in the redzone. In fact it was downright terrifying to be on defense, pinned by the Joe Burrow led offense. Matt Rhule responded to Teddy's comments...

So Matt Rhule defended the practice methods. Is it possible that as head coach he directed how practices went? Absolutely. That's quite literally 1 of the defining jobs of the Head Coach. But its just speculation. So then why are the Bills so good in the redzone? Turns out, they focus on that in practice. Alot.


In fact, if you google around, you're hit with article after article of their red zone practices. Furthermore, that specific article states "Joe Brady took the offense into the redzone to work on the specifics of their playbook in 11 v 11 work".

So is it possible the lack of red zone work was under the preference of Matt Rhule? Absolutely. But we know this. Joe Brady practices red zone with the Bills, and is in large part why they are one of the top scoring offenses in the league. So either way you slice it. You can say "Its Matt Rhules fault". Or, you can say "Its Joe Brady's fault but he clearly learned from that mistake".

Either way, based on the adaptability, the mistakes and alterations to fix those mistakes, even down to the play calling, we're seeing a lot from Joe Brady. Possibly even more then we saw from Sean Payton at his time in OC.

I'm also curious, what do previous players have to say about Joe Brady.

“Joe’s awesome, Joe’s very creative,” Burrow said. “He always has something for a certain look that you’re seeing on tape to take advantage of that. It’s a big opportunity for him, I’m excited for him. He helped me a lot. He helped me become the player I am today. Nothing but love for Joe.” - Burrow.

So Burrow credits his success to Joe Brady.


"His thinking is if you guys want it, you'll make it work. He puts all the trust in us and we try to reciprocate that back to him and give him everything that we got," Allen added.

So, Joe Burrow has a career year under Joe Brady at LSU, Teddy Bridgewater has a career year under Joe Brady despite a low scoring offense that may, or may not have been hindered by Matt Rhules practice philosphy. Josh Allen is having a career year, attributes a lot of it to Joe Brady....

Give me Joe Brady as Head Coach.
 
Over the past couple of weeks I've grown on the simple idea that Joe Brady is a better candidate than Ben Johnson.

First and foremost, Brady seems to be a QB whisperer. This is obvious from as early as his days at LSU with Burrow at QB as the passing game coordinator. The following article highlights that his ideas helped propel the offense and helped Joe Burrow go from 16 TD's the previous season to 60.


From there he went to Carolina in 2020. It's no secret that the Panthers sucked under Matt Rhule. Joe Brady was fired later Dec 5th in the 2021 season. The Panthers never really took off offensively. But were they that bad? Is it possible that Joe Brady was a scapegoat? Yes. And that the same time No. Teddy Bridgewater had arguably his best season ever under Joe Brady throwing for 3700+ yards. Mike Davis had over 1000 yards from scrimmage. So what was the problem? Scoring. Teddy Bridgewater, after being traded informed on a podcast with Patrick Peterson that Joe Brady never practiced Red Zone, nor 2 minute drills in practice.

It showed. The Panthers were in the bottom half of scoring, despite having an offense that could drive the middle, and back half of the field with no problems.


But why? LSU's offense was quite good in the redzone. In fact it was downright terrifying to be on defense, pinned by the Joe Burrow led offense. Matt Rhule responded to Teddy's comments...

So Matt Rhule defended the practice methods. Is it possible that as head coach he directed how practices went? Absolutely. That's quite literally 1 of the defining jobs of the Head Coach. But its just speculation. So then why are the Bills so good in the redzone? Turns out, they focus on that in practice. Alot.


In fact, if you google around, you're hit with article after article of their red zone practices. Furthermore, that specific article states "Joe Brady took the offense into the redzone to work on the specifics of their playbook in 11 v 11 work".

So is it possible the lack of red zone work was under the preference of Matt Rhule? Absolutely. But we know this. Joe Brady practices red zone with the Bills, and is in large part why they are one of the top scoring offenses in the league. So either way you slice it. You can say "Its Matt Rhules fault". Or, you can say "Its Joe Brady's fault but he clearly learned from that mistake".

Either way, based on the adaptability, the mistakes and alterations to fix those mistakes, even down to the play calling, we're seeing a lot from Joe Brady. Possibly even more then we saw from Sean Payton at his time in OC.

I'm also curious, what do previous players have to say about Joe Brady.

“Joe’s awesome, Joe’s very creative,” Burrow said. “He always has something for a certain look that you’re seeing on tape to take advantage of that. It’s a big opportunity for him, I’m excited for him. He helped me a lot. He helped me become the player I am today. Nothing but love for Joe.” - Burrow.

So Burrow credits his success to Joe Brady.


"His thinking is if you guys want it, you'll make it work. He puts all the trust in us and we try to reciprocate that back to him and give him everything that we got," Allen added.

So, Joe Burrow has a career year under Joe Brady at LSU, Teddy Bridgewater has a career year under Joe Brady despite a low scoring offense that may, or may not have been hindered by Matt Rhules practice philosphy. Josh Allen is having a career year, attributes a lot of it to Joe Brady....

Give me Joe Brady as Head Coach.
"But he has ties to Payton."
Lol
 
Right now I am going to wait to see what's out there before I make my choice but Brady is on my radar. He made Burrows a Heisman. Now Josh Allen is the leading candidate for MVP.
 
I think the only reason people are behind him is because of the LSU connection.

I clearly showed how QB's tend to have their best years under him, going all the way from LSU with Burrow, even with the Panthers (except Sam Darnold), and now the Bills. LSU connection or not, that's an incredible track record.
 
Give me Ben Johnson all day everyday over Joe Brady. Not even close IMO.

Brady looked absolutely horrible with the Panthers and was ran out of town with the Bills.

Huh? He's currently the Bills OC. His only negative stint was with the Panthers but everyone outside a few purple and gold homers knew Brady was nowhere near ready to be an NFL OC at that time. He's since learned and grown with the Bills as their QB Coach to Interim OC to now official OC of the Bills and they were the #6 scoring offense with him last season and #2 in scoring this season. He also just annihilated Aaron Glenn who a growing number of people want/think will be the next Saints Head Coach.

That said, I still go all-in on Ben Johnson. Johnson has a far more impressive resume and I think he's got what it takes to be a great Head Coach.
 
I clearly showed how QB's tend to have their best years under him, going all the way from LSU with Burrow, even with the Panthers (except Sam Darnold), and now the Bills. LSU connection or not, that's an incredible track record.
You’re making a good argument for QB coach and OC jobs, but that doesn’t address uncertainty about whether he’s ready and capable of being a successful head coach. Which is going to be true for any first time hire, but I think it sticks out a little more for a guy with a thinner resume.

I’m not knocking him, and agree that he’ll be a candidate this cycle or as soon as he wants to be, but it’s going to take a lot more than can he work wonders with a QB. He’ll have to be exceptional in interviews to convince an owner he is ready to run the day-to-day of an entire team.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom