New DCU Plans (2 Viewers)

Not a popular opinion, but I'm a Melissa Benoist version of Supergirl fan.
That's a negative sir. Everything we loved about Superman and Lois was the complete opposite on Supergirl. It was DOA after its budget was cut after the first season and they move it to the CW. It became unwatchable after that.
 
I meant both. I'm not into a campy Supergirl, which Benoist personified. Sasha Calle was far better.
I don't really care for the campy SG either, but I always thought she looks like a Supergirl should. I think she could play a more serious SG, but that's not what the TV show was. I think she was handcuffed by the writing and directing. I say put her in a real SG movie, but probably won't happen.

Sasha is awesome, but I don't really care for her look as SG.
 
I don't really care for the campy SG either, but I always thought she looks like a Supergirl should. I think she could play a more serious SG, but that's not what the TV show was. I think she was handcuffed by the writing and directing. I say put her in a real SG movie, but probably won't happen.

Sasha is awesome, but I don't really care for her look as SG.
I didn't like nor dislike Sasha as SG. I thought she was okay, nothing special. I didn't get why people thought she was so great.
 
I didn't like nor dislike Sasha as SG. I thought she was okay, nothing special. I didn't get why people thought she was so great.
Yeah, for me, I think a Kara Zor-El look is more Melissa than Sasha, but that's me.

And I think we all agree that the Supergirl TV show wasn't a good a good show for a lot of reasons. I watched all of it only because it was part of the Arrowverse and crossover shows.

That said, I think part of the issue is the writers had CW type agenda and that hurt the show.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Users who are viewing this thread

    Back
    Top Bottom