ROY "curve ball" (1 Viewer)

ndcc

Saints' fan 4ever
VIP Subscribing Member
Gold VIP Contributor
Joined
Jun 4, 2005
Messages
18,139
Reaction score
23,896
Location
Sad to leave NOLA to AZ; going into ministry
Offline
Need to know what others think about this:

With Colston doing as well as he has, and A.J. Hawk staying within striking distance (for the most part), what effect would Reggie getting hot for the rest of the year do to the voting?

Before you jump, here's my thinking:

Let's say you have about 40% thinking it's Colston so far...

And assume about 30% right now think it's A.J. Hawk.

Assume 5% are thinking Bush right now just from pure bias or whatever.

The other 25% split amongst the other candidates.

Then, let Bush get hot (and show up on several highlight reels). The Saints start to make a push, and the talk increases on how he has been an important weapon this season.

Colston & Hawk will more than likely continue to shine as they already have.

Then, you have a late surge of opinion that places more emphasis on Bush. If you weigh the season strictly based on game-by-game performance, I believe that Marques would probably deserve it (even if Bush has a late surge).

But we all know how the politics of things works. And if the Saints make the playoffs, and the Packers don't ... you might get a "sympathy" vote for A.J. Hawk if the three rookies are within 10 percentage points of each other... logic being that the Saints made the postseason, and at least let Green Bay rejoice for something.

For those who think this is out to lunch, there are some who still believe that Chris Paul won the NBA ROY because some voters gave him (and the city) a sympathy vote because of Katrina (BTW, I believe C.P. was well deserving of the award).

Maybe there are other opinions, but I kinda think that if Reggie's performance heats-up, it will draw more votes away from Colston than A.J. Hawk (...for the reasons cited above).

Other thoughts? :16:
 

Paul

Professional
Joined
Oct 20, 2004
Messages
16,410
Reaction score
11,367
Age
44
Offline
My first thought is that I am almost certain that there are two separate awards: one for Offensive ROY & Defensive ROY. If so, then it would eliminate Hawk from the discussion between Bush & Colston.
 

Dre

More than 15K posts served!
Joined
Nov 18, 2000
Messages
16,704
Reaction score
4,754
Age
41
Offline
I dont think they will give the vote to Hawk for sympathy for a bad team (I didnt even know he was playing so well, but that is another subject). Theoretically it is possible that Bush pull voted away from Colston, but that is assuming he gets the ball more. I would think Bush would start to do better with the same amount of opportunities...in that case Colston should continue to put up his great numbers. But if for whatever reason Bush startes to get more touches, then it is possible that could take away from Colston's touches...but I doubt that would happen.
 

CajunSaint

Hall of Famer
Gold VIP Contributor
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
7,379
Reaction score
7,803
Location
Metry...Missing Lafayette.
Offline
I dont think they will give the vote to Hawk for sympathy for a bad team (I didnt even know he was playing so well, but that is another subject).


For starters, we have established that there are seperate awards for Offense and Defense....with that said, Hawk isnt even the leading candidate on the defensive side of the ball. Hawk needs to worry about beating out candidates like Demeco Ryans, Mark Anderson, Antoine Bethea, Dawan Landry, and Ernie Sims.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)



Headlines

Top Bottom