Where Does Derek Carr’s Career Rank in Saints Franchise History? (2 Viewers)

[kcirdor]

b/w 6th to 8th... according to the stats....

 

[RebSaint]

Probably akin to Jim Everette

 

[Kramer]

Carr ranks 2nd in comp %, 8th in passing yards, 6th in wins.

Other than Brees and Hebert, he is the only Saints QB that has 10 or more wins and a winning record as starting QB.

I would listen to an argument for Hebert or Brooks to be higher than Carr, but that's it.

Fact: Hebert never lost to an AFC team as a starter. I find that impressive. How many other Saints quarterbacks can you name that was undefeated against AFC teams as a starter?

 

[Kramer]

Probably akin to Jim Everette

You mean Chrissy?

 

[RebSaint]

You mean Chrissy?

Yep. He couldn’t make it in NO, but he made Jim Rome’s career.

 

[SigFreudianSlip]

This made me lol.

 

[1K SPORT]

Dude has played what, 25ish unspectacular games as a Saint? In a few years people will have to be reminded he actually played here unless people are talking about bad contracts.

 

[DougieV]

He's Wuerffel..

 

[boutte]

I'd put Archie at 3 and I think it's fair. Give Archie the Dome Patrol and we don't have to wait for Aaron Brooks to have a playoff win.

Who do you have as #2? (Please don't say AAron Brooks)

 

[boutte]

Brees
Manning
Kilmer
Hebert

After that it's just a sheet show. (Stabler was the worst.)

 

[Kramer]

Brees
Manning
Kilmer
Hebert

After that it's just a sheet show. (Stabler was the worst.)

To me it's:

Brees
Hebert
Manning
Brooks


As I said earlier in the thread, Hebert is the only Saints quarterback who was undefeated against AFC teams as a starter. Frank Gifford mentioned it on a Monday Night Football game showing a stat on screen about it.

 

[UFCSaint]

You know who the real “what if?” quarterback was for this team? Kerry Collins.

He was behind the 8 ball from the jump due to when he joined the team, and under the coaching staff he was under, but under a better coach, he got a team to a Super Bowl.

Now THAT guy drank...

 

[UFCSaint]

1) Drew (one two win for you)
2) Manning (Arch)
3) Manning (Archie)
4) Hebert (longevity/personality over Brooks)
5) Brooks (flawed, but first playoff win)
5) Jim Everett (better days were behind him)
6) Stabler (better days were behind him)
7) Jameis (flawed, but he had talent and he tried)
8) Taysom (Swiss Army etc.)
9) Billy Joe #1 (will be forgotten except for name)
10) Billy Joe #2 (will be forgotten except for name)
.
.
.
Carr (flawed, and better days were behind him, and will be forgotten except for name)

I'm sorry... Why is Arch on this list?

 

[UFCSaint]

lol he was found on Bourbon St passed out drunk when he was the QB here.

It’s just a joke about Chris, I mean Jim

You sure you're not thinking of Kerry Collins?